Gul Arif, Batra Sameer, Mehmood Shahid, Gillham Nick
Department of Orthopaedics, Gwynedd Hospital, Bangor, Gwynedd, United Kingdom.
Acta Orthop Belg. 2007 Jun;73(3):360-5.
The objective of this study was to determine whether immediate mobilisation and unprotected weight-bearing of rigidly internally fixed fractured ankles had a significant effect on ankle function or whether it predisposed the ankle to loss of reduction or hardware failure. Twenty five patients with operated Weber A/B/C fractures were allowed immediate full weight-bearing without a plaster and were compared with matched historical controls treated in a non-weight-bearing plaster cast. Matched-pair analysis revealed no differences for hospital stay and functional outcome on Olerud and Molander scoring system but significant difference in time until return to work (mean: 91.3 +/- 20.2 vs. 54.6 +/- 15.5 days). In the cast group four patients had postoperative complications; one patient had loss of internal fixation and one had non-union while four patients in the non cast group had mainly wound-healing related problems. Patients in the non cast group tolerated earlier full weight-bearing compared with patients in the cast group, and there were no disadvantages concerning hospital stay, pain intensities, and functional scores. Treating patients without plaster may result in faster rehabilitation.
本研究的目的是确定对于采用坚强内固定的踝关节骨折患者,立即进行活动及无保护负重是否会对踝关节功能产生显著影响,或者是否会使踝关节易于出现复位丢失或内固定失败。25例接受手术治疗的Weber A/B/C型骨折患者被允许立即完全负重且无需石膏固定,并与采用非负重石膏固定治疗的配对历史对照患者进行比较。配对分析显示,在Olerud和Molander评分系统中,住院时间和功能结局无差异,但恢复工作的时间存在显著差异(平均:91.3±20.2天对54.6±15.5天)。石膏固定组有4例患者出现术后并发症;1例患者内固定失败,1例患者出现骨不连,而非石膏固定组的4例患者主要出现与伤口愈合相关的问题。与石膏固定组患者相比,非石膏固定组患者能耐受更早的完全负重,且在住院时间、疼痛强度和功能评分方面没有不利影响。不使用石膏治疗患者可能会使康复更快。