Science. 1974 Nov 1;186(4162):440-3. doi: 10.1126/science.186.4162.440.
The available compositional data on planets and satellites can be used to place stringent limits on the thermal environment in the solar nebula. The densities of the terrestrial planets, Ceres and Vesta, the Galilean satellites, and Titan; the atmospheric compositions of several of these bodies; and geochemical and geophysical data on the earth combine to define a strong dependence of formation temperature on heliocentric distance. The pressure and temperature dependences of the condensation process are separable in the sense that the variation of the deduced formation temperatures with heliocentric distance is insensitive to even very diverse assumptions regarding the pressure profile in the nebula. It is impossible to reconcile the available compositional data with any model in which the formation temperatures of these bodies are determined by radiative equilibrium with the sun, regardless of the sun's luminosity. Rather, the data support Cameron's hypothesis of a dense, convective solar nebula, opaque to solar radiation, with an adiabatic temperature-pressure profile.
可利用的行星和卫星成分数据可用来对太阳星云的热环境施加严格的限制。类地行星(如:谷神星、灶神星)、伽利略卫星和土卫六的密度;这些天体的部分大气成分;以及地球上的地球化学和地球物理数据结合起来定义了形成温度与日心距离的强烈依赖关系。在凝聚过程中,压力和温度的依赖性是可分离的,因为从推断的形成温度随日心距离的变化对星云内压力分布的假设非常多样化并不敏感。无论太阳的光度如何,这些天体的形成温度都由与太阳的辐射平衡决定,这与现有的成分数据是无法协调的。相反,这些数据支持卡梅伦的假设,即太阳星云是密集的、对流的、对太阳辐射不透明的,具有绝热温度-压力分布。