Hallam A
Science. 1987 Nov 27;238(4831):1237-42. doi: 10.1126/science.238.4831.1237.
The end-Cretaceous mass extinctions were not a geologically instantaneous event and were selective in character. These features are incompatible with the original Alvarez hypothesis of their being caused by a single asteroid impact that produced a world-embracing dust cloud with devastating environmental consequences. By analysis of physical and chemical evidence from the stratigraphic record it is shown that a modified extraterrestrial model in which stepwise extinctions resulted from encounter with a comet shower is less plausible than one intrinsic to the earth, involving significant disturbance in the mantle.
白垩纪末期的大规模灭绝并非地质瞬间事件,且具有选择性。这些特征与阿尔瓦雷斯最初提出的假说不相符,该假说认为它们是由一颗小行星撞击导致的,撞击产生了笼罩全球的尘埃云,带来了毁灭性的环境后果。通过对地层记录中的物理和化学证据进行分析表明,一种修正后的外星模型(即与彗星雨遭遇导致逐步灭绝)比一种与地球内在相关的模型(涉及地幔的重大扰动)更不合理。