Cleary-Goldman Jane, Bettes Barbara, Robinson Julian N, Norwitz Errol, Schulkin Jay
Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Mount Sinai School of Medicine, New York, New York, USA.
Obstet Gynecol. 2007 Sep;110(3):669-74. doi: 10.1097/01.AOG.0000278597.40292.32.
To examine how practicing obstetricians evaluate and manage thrombophilias in selected clinical situations.
A questionnaire investigating knowledge and practice patterns pertaining to thrombophilia was mailed to 300 randomly selected American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists Fellows and Junior Fellows in February 2005.
Approximately 50% (151) of questionnaires were returned. Statistical analysis focused on the 104 responding obstetricians. The majority (greater than 70%) know which thrombophilias are inherited and which are acquired. More than 50% send an inherited thrombophilia panel and antiphospholipid antibodies on patients with a history of fetal demise, intrauterine growth restriction (less than 5th percentile), abruption, and severe preeclampsia. Ninety-two percent test patients with recurrent miscarriages for antiphospholipid antibodies. Despite no clear evidence, 80% also test these patients for inherited thrombophilias. The majority intervene with either thromboprophylaxis or low-dose aspirin when managing patients at risk for thromboembolism. Seventy percent use low-molecular-weight (fractionated) heparin for patients requiring therapeutic anticoagulation, while 62% also use it for prophylactic anticoagulation. Thirty-eight percent of physicians using low-molecular-weight (fractionated) heparin monitor anti-factor Xa levels. The majority (56%) felt their residency training with regard to thrombophilia was barely adequate. Only 8% felt their training was comprehensive, while 36% felt it was adequate.
Most responding obstetricians do not manage thrombophilia patients according to expert opinion. Despite the fact that often there is no clear evidence for treatment, many physicians are inclined to intervene in patients at risk for thromboembolism. Educational endeavors are needed to guide obstetricians caring for patients at risk for thromboembolism.
III.
探讨执业产科医生在特定临床情况下如何评估和处理血栓形成倾向。
2005年2月,一份关于血栓形成倾向相关知识和实践模式的调查问卷被邮寄给300名随机挑选的美国妇产科医师学会会员和初级会员。
大约50%(151份)问卷被返还。统计分析集中于104名做出回应的产科医生。大多数(超过70%)知道哪些血栓形成倾向是遗传性的,哪些是后天获得性的。超过50%的医生会为有胎儿死亡、宫内生长受限(低于第5百分位数)、胎盘早剥和重度子痫前期病史的患者进行遗传性血栓形成倾向检测及抗磷脂抗体检测。92%的医生会对复发性流产患者进行抗磷脂抗体检测。尽管没有明确证据,80%的医生也会对这些患者进行遗传性血栓形成倾向检测。在处理有血栓栓塞风险的患者时,大多数医生会采取血栓预防措施或使用低剂量阿司匹林。70%的医生在需要治疗性抗凝的患者中使用低分子(分级)肝素,62%的医生也将其用于预防性抗凝。使用低分子(分级)肝素的医生中有38%会监测抗Xa因子水平。大多数(56%)医生认为他们在住院医师培训期间关于血栓形成倾向的内容勉强足够。只有8%的医生认为培训内容全面,36%的医生认为足够。
大多数做出回应的产科医生没有按照专家意见处理血栓形成倾向患者。尽管通常没有明确的治疗证据,但许多医生倾向于对有血栓栓塞风险患者进行干预。需要开展教育活动来指导产科医生护理有血栓栓塞风险的患者。
III级