McDaniel Carl N, Lister Bradford C, Hanna Michael H, Roy Harry
Department of Biology, Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute, Troy, NY 12180, USA.
CBE Life Sci Educ. 2007 Fall;6(3):243-9. doi: 10.1187/cbe.07-01-0003.
Our Introduction to Biology course (BIOL 1010) changed in 2004 from a standard instructor-centered, lecture-homework-exam format to a student-centered format that used Web-enhanced, interactive pedagogy. To measure and compare conceptual learning gains in the traditional course in fall 2003 with a section of the interactive course in fall 2004, we created concept inventories for both evolution and ecology. Both classes were taught by the same instructor who had taught BIOL 1010 since 1976, and each had a similar student composition with comparable biological knowledge. A significant increase in learning gain was observed with the Web-enhanced, interactive pedagogy in evolution (traditional, 0.10; interactive, 0.19; p = 0.024) and ecology (traditional, -0.05; interactive, 0.14; p = 0.000009) when assessment was made unannounced and for no credit in the last week of classes. These results strengthen the case for augmenting or replacing instructor-centered teaching with Web-enhanced, interactive, student-centered teaching. When assessment was made using the final exam in the interactive course, for credit and after studying, significantly greater learning gains were made in evolution (95%, 0.37, p = 0.0001) and ecology (143%, 0.34, p = 0.000003) when compared with learning gains measured without credit or study in the last week of classes.
我们的生物学入门课程(BIOL 1010)在2004年从标准的以教师为中心的讲座-作业-考试模式转变为以学生为中心的模式,采用了网络增强的交互式教学法。为了衡量和比较2003年秋季传统课程与2004年秋季交互式课程部分中的概念学习收获,我们为进化和生态创建了概念清单。两个班级均由同一位自1976年起就教授BIOL 1010的教师授课,且每个班级的学生构成相似,生物知识水平相当。在课程最后一周进行不预先通知且不计成绩的评估时,网络增强的交互式教学法在进化(传统课程,0.10;交互式课程,0.19;p = 0.024)和生态(传统课程,-0.05;交互式课程,0.14;p = 0.000009)方面的学习收获有显著提高。这些结果进一步证明了用网络增强的、交互式的、以学生为中心的教学来扩充或取代以教师为中心的教学的合理性。当在交互式课程中使用期末考试进行评估、计成绩且在学习之后时,与在课程最后一周不计成绩或不学习的情况下所测得的学习收获相比,进化(提高95%,0.37,p = 0.0001)和生态(提高143%,0.34,p = 0.000003)方面取得了显著更大的学习收获。