Taylor Edward W, Tisdell Elizabeth J, Gusic Maryellen E
Penn State University, Harrisburg, Middletown, PA, USA.
Med Teach. 2007 May;29(4):371-6. doi: 10.1080/01421590701510553.
Most who teach in clinical settings see themselves primarily as clinicians or physicians responsible for patient care and only secondarily as educators. The education literature suggests that teaching predominantly operates at a tacit level, where teachers rely on core beliefs to guide their practice, and actually spend little time in reflective practice. Given the lack of research on how medical educators in clinical settings view their teaching, the purpose of this qualitative study was to explore the teaching beliefs of faculty in a pediatrics department in a college of medicine.
Using a Teaching Perspectives Inventory, observations and in-depth interviews, a complex picture was revealed about teaching beliefs of medical educators.
Due to contextual constraints of the clinical setting (e.g., time, competing stakeholders) that requires primary attention to patient care, they describe 'teaching on the fly'. There is a strong emphasis on: delivering content; encouraging thinking among students; providing questioning and engaging learning experiences; and respecting students as learners.
The implications of these beliefs are significant and indicate that faculty can benefit from opportunities that make their beliefs about teaching more conscious, particularly in determining how best to prepare future physicians to teach in clinical settings.
大多数在临床环境中教学的人主要将自己视为负责患者护理的临床医生或内科医生,其次才是教育工作者。教育文献表明,教学主要在隐性层面进行,教师依靠核心信念来指导实践,实际上很少花时间进行反思性实践。鉴于缺乏关于临床环境中的医学教育工作者如何看待其教学的研究,这项定性研究的目的是探索一所医学院校儿科系教师的教学信念。
通过使用教学观点量表、观察和深入访谈,揭示了医学教育工作者教学信念的复杂情况。
由于临床环境的背景限制(如时间、相互竞争的利益相关者)要求首要关注患者护理,他们描述了“即兴教学”。重点强调:传授内容;鼓励学生思考;提供提问和引人入胜的学习体验;以及尊重学生作为学习者。
这些信念的影响重大,表明教师可以从使他们对教学的信念更加明确的机会中受益,特别是在确定如何最好地培养未来医生在临床环境中进行教学方面。