Bunderson Nathan E, Ting Lena H, Burkholder Thomas J
Department of Biomedical Engineering, Georgia Institute of Technology and Emory University, Atlanta, GA 30332, USA.
J Neural Eng. 2007 Sep;4(3):234-45. doi: 10.1088/1741-2560/4/3/009. Epub 2007 May 4.
Maintaining the postural configuration of a limb such as an arm or leg is a fundamental neural control task that involves the coordination of multiple linked body segments. Biological systems are known to use a complex network of inter- and intra-joint feedback mechanisms arising from muscles, spinal reflexes and higher neuronal structures to stabilize the limbs. While previous work has shown that a small amount of asymmetric heterogenic feedback contributes to the behavior of these systems, a satisfactory functional explanation for this non-conservative feedback structure has not been put forth. We hypothesized that an asymmetric multi-joint control strategy would confer both an energetic and stability advantage in maintaining endpoint position of a kinematically redundant system. We tested this hypothesis by using optimal control models incorporating symmetric versus asymmetric feedback with the goal of maintaining the endpoint location of a kinematically redundant, planar limb. Asymmetric feedback improved endpoint control performance of the limb by 16%, reduced energetic cost by 21% and increased interjoint coordination by 40% compared to the symmetric feedback system. The overall effect of the asymmetry was that proximal joint motion resulted in greater torque generation at distal joints than vice versa. The asymmetric organization is consistent with heterogenic stretch reflex gains measured experimentally. We conclude that asymmetric feedback has a functionally relevant role in coordinating redundant degrees of freedom to maintain the position of the hand or foot.
维持诸如手臂或腿部等肢体的姿势构型是一项基本的神经控制任务,它涉及多个相连身体节段的协调。已知生物系统利用由肌肉、脊髓反射和更高层次神经元结构产生的关节间和关节内反馈机制的复杂网络来稳定肢体。虽然先前的研究表明少量的不对称异源反馈有助于这些系统的行为,但尚未对这种非保守反馈结构给出令人满意的功能解释。我们假设一种不对称多关节控制策略在维持运动学冗余系统的端点位置方面将兼具能量和稳定性优势。我们通过使用纳入对称与不对称反馈的最优控制模型来检验这一假设,目的是维持运动学冗余平面肢体的端点位置。与对称反馈系统相比,不对称反馈使肢体的端点控制性能提高了16%,能量消耗降低了21%,关节间协调性提高了40%。不对称的总体效果是近端关节运动在远端关节产生的扭矩大于反之情况。这种不对称组织与实验测量的异源牵张反射增益一致。我们得出结论,不对称反馈在协调冗余自由度以维持手或脚的位置方面具有功能上相关的作用。