Mulder Sanna A, van Leerdam Monique E, van Vuuren Anneke J, Francke Jan, van Toorenenbergen Albert W, Kuipers Ernst J, Ouwendijk Rob J Th
Department of Gastroenterology, Ikazia Ziekenhuis, Montessoriweg 1, Erasmus Medical Center, Dr Molewaterplein 40, Rotterdam, The Netherlands.
Eur J Gastroenterol Hepatol. 2007 Oct;19(10):878-82. doi: 10.1097/MEG.0b013e3282cfa49c.
Immunochemical fecal occult blood test (FOBT) and determination of tumor pyruvate kinase isoenzyme type M2 (TuM2-PK) in stool samples may be valuable new screening tools for colorectal cancer (CRC). The aim of this study was to compare the accuracy of fecal TuM2-PK testing with immunochemical FOBT in patients with CRC or adenomas.
A total of 52 patients with CRC were analyzed, 47 with colorectal adenomas, and 63 matched controls with a normal colonoscopy. Nineteen additional patients with inflammatory bowel disease were tested to determine influence of inflammation. Stool samples were analyzed with two immunochemical FOBTs, Immo-care and OC-Light, and with a commercial enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for TuM2-PK.
In patients with CRC, the sensitivity of TuM2-PK, Immo-care and OC-Light was respectively 85, 92 and 94%. In patients with adenomas, the sensitivity was respectively 28, 40 and 34%. Specificity for these tests was 90% for TuM2-PK and 97% for both immunochemical FOBTs. All tests showed a high positivity rate in patients with inflammatory bowel disease (79% for TuM2-PK and Immo-care, and 89% for OC-Light).
Both immunochemical FOBTs appear valuable and are sensitive tests for CRC screening. TuM2-PK does not have supplemental value for screening for CRC because of a lower sensitivity and specificity. None of these tests is sensitive enough for detection of advanced adenomas. Patients with inflammatory bowel disease should be excluded from CRC screening when using immunochemical FOBT or TuM2-PK.
免疫化学粪便潜血试验(FOBT)以及粪便样本中肿瘤丙酮酸激酶M2型(TuM2-PK)的检测可能是用于结直肠癌(CRC)筛查的有价值的新工具。本研究的目的是比较粪便TuM2-PK检测与免疫化学FOBT在CRC患者或腺瘤患者中的准确性。
共分析了52例CRC患者、47例结直肠腺瘤患者以及63例结肠镜检查正常的匹配对照。另外对19例炎症性肠病患者进行检测以确定炎症的影响。粪便样本采用两种免疫化学FOBT(Immo-care和OC-Light)以及一种用于TuM2-PK的商业酶联免疫吸附测定法进行分析。
在CRC患者中,TuM2-PK、Immo-care和OC-Light的敏感性分别为85%、92%和94%。在腺瘤患者中,敏感性分别为28%、40%和34%。这些检测的特异性对于TuM2-PK为90%,对于两种免疫化学FOBT均为97%。所有检测在炎症性肠病患者中均显示出高阳性率(TuM2-PK和Immo-care为79%,OC-Light为89%)。
两种免疫化学FOBT似乎都有价值,并且是用于CRC筛查的敏感检测方法。由于敏感性和特异性较低,TuM2-PK在CRC筛查中没有补充价值。这些检测方法均不足以敏感地检测出高级别腺瘤。使用免疫化学FOBT或TuM2-PK进行CRC筛查时,应将炎症性肠病患者排除在外。