Loganayagam A
Department of Gastroenterology, King's College Hospital, Denmark Hill, London, UK.
Int J Clin Pract. 2008 Mar;62(3):454-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1742-1241.2007.01532.x. Epub 2007 Sep 20.
Screening and prevention of colorectal cancer (CRC) is a public health priority. Recent progress in understanding the biology of CRC has lead to possible new approaches to screening. In particular, assay of faecal molecular markers represents a promising non-invasive approach to screening, with improved safety, accuracy and patient compliance.
MEDLINE/PubMed searches were used to identify key articles relating to faecal-based screening with secondary review of cited publications.
Faecal markers of CRC can be broadly divided into DNA based and non-DNA based.
Faecal occult blood testing for CRC screening has been advocated for decades for its non-invasiveness and low cost. It has exhibited a 15-33% decrease in mortality, despite drawbacks with sensitivity and compliance. Other non-DNA markers have the adequate sensitivity for inflammatory lesions but do not have the required specificity for screening average-risk populations. Faecal DNA testing has the potential to enhance the performance characteristics of stool testing. Because of molecular heterogeneity of cancer, no single DNA marker has yielded adequate sensitivity. Analysis of several combinations of markers in studies have produced high detection rates of both CRC and advanced adenomas in selected patient groups. However, the currently available markers, both non-DNA and DNA, have not yet been validated in large-scale studies screening average -risk population nor have they so far shown the necessary sensitivity and specificity required for large-scale screening programmes. Another major drawback with the DNA-based markers is the cost-effectiveness. Issues regarding implementation and compliance remain unanswered. These critical problems have to be rectified before these techniques can be recommended for large-scale CRC screening.
结直肠癌(CRC)的筛查与预防是公共卫生的重点。在了解结直肠癌生物学方面的最新进展带来了可能的新筛查方法。特别是,粪便分子标志物检测代表了一种有前景的非侵入性筛查方法,具有更高的安全性、准确性和患者依从性。
使用MEDLINE/PubMed检索来识别与基于粪便的筛查相关的关键文章,并对引用的出版物进行二次审查。
结直肠癌的粪便标志物可大致分为基于DNA的和非基于DNA的。
数十年来,粪便潜血检测因其非侵入性和低成本一直被提倡用于结直肠癌筛查。尽管存在敏感性和依从性方面的缺点,但它已使死亡率降低了15%至33%。其他非DNA标志物对炎症性病变具有足够的敏感性,但对筛查平均风险人群没有所需的特异性。粪便DNA检测有可能提高粪便检测的性能特征。由于癌症的分子异质性,没有单一的DNA标志物具有足够的敏感性。研究中对几种标志物组合的分析在选定患者群体中产生了结直肠癌和高级别腺瘤的高检出率。然而,目前可用的标志物,无论是非DNA的还是DNA的,尚未在大规模筛查平均风险人群的研究中得到验证,到目前为止也未显示出大规模筛查计划所需的必要敏感性和特异性。基于DNA的标志物的另一个主要缺点是成本效益。关于实施和依从性的问题仍未得到解答。在这些技术被推荐用于大规模结直肠癌筛查之前,这些关键问题必须得到解决。