Center for Research and Development of Education at UMC Utrecht, the Netherlands.
Med Teach. 2007 Sep;29(6):591-9. doi: 10.1080/01421590701606799.
To provide an estimation of how often peer teaching is applied in medical education, based on reports in the literature and to summarize reasons that support the use of this form of teaching.
We surveyed the 2006 medical education literature and categorised reports of peer teaching according to educational distance between students teaching and students taught, group size, and level of formality of the teaching. Subsequently, we analysed the rationales for applying peer teaching.
Most reports were published abstracts in either Medical Education's annual feature 'Really Good Stuff' or the AMEE's annual conference proceedings. We identified twelve distinct reasons to apply peer teaching, including 'alleviating faculty teaching burden', 'providing role models for junior students', 'enhancing intrinsic motivation' and 'preparing physicians for their future role as educators'.
Peer teaching appears to be practiced often, but many peer teaching reports do not become full length journal articles. We conclude that specifically 'near-peer teaching' appears beneficial for student teachers and learners as well as for the organisation. The analogy of the 'journeyman', as intermediate between 'apprentice' and 'master', with both learning and teaching tasks, is a valuable but yet under-recognized source of education in the medical education continuum.
根据文献报道,评估同伴教学在医学教育中的应用频率,并总结支持这种教学形式的应用的原因。
我们调查了 2006 年的医学教育文献,并根据学生教学和学生学习之间的教育距离、小组规模以及教学形式的正式程度对同伴教学的报告进行了分类。随后,我们分析了应用同伴教学的理由。
大多数报告是在《医学教育》年度专题“真的很不错”或 AMEE 年度会议论文集中发表的摘要。我们确定了应用同伴教学的 12 个不同的理由,包括“减轻教师的教学负担”、“为低年级学生提供榜样”、“增强内在动机”和“为医生未来的教育者角色做准备”。
同伴教学似乎经常被采用,但许多同伴教学报告并没有成为完整的期刊文章。我们的结论是,特别是“近同伴教学”对学生教师和学习者以及对组织都有益。“熟练工”的类比,作为“学徒”和“师傅”之间的中间角色,具有学习和教学任务,是医学教育连续体中一个有价值但尚未被充分认识的教育来源。