Chapper Ana, Campani Simone A, Paiva Verônica da S, de Assis Camila de A, Garcia Eduardo, Abreu e Silva Fernando A
Medical School, Universidade Federal do Rio Grande do Sul, Porto Alegre, Brazil.
J Dent Educ. 2007 Oct;71(10):1363-9.
This study compared perceptions of the teaching and learning process of twenty-four senior dental students from a public school and fifteen from a private school by means of a questionnaire with direct questions. Another five students in each group completed a qualitative survey with five open-ended questions. The questionnaires assessed perceptions of the interaction between didactic and clinical content, the role of professors during the course, and their future professional practice in Brazil. Quantitative data were summarized as means and standard deviations and statistically analyzed with the Student t test, P<0.05. Qualitative data were analyzed using a content analysis method. The results revealed that the students in the private school had more positive perceptions than those in the public school of how much the didactic classes contributed to professional practice, the level of motivation for the topics discussed, and how well coursework related to clinical practice. Both groups mentioned the importance of the clinical component of learning and perceived that professors showed little commitment to the professional preparation of dental students. Students' perceptions of their preparation to work in different Brazilian communities and with different segments of society varied widely. The qualitative analyses confirmed students' dissatisfaction with their learning. No difference was found between students in the public and private schools in their assessment of how well prepared they were to enter the working market. These findings indicate that measures should be taken to improve the quality of teaching and the satisfaction of dental school students in Brazil.
本研究通过一份包含直接问题的问卷,比较了公立学校的24名高年级牙科学生和私立学校的15名高年级牙科学生对教学过程的看法。每组另外5名学生完成了一项包含5个开放式问题的定性调查。问卷评估了对理论教学与临床内容之间互动的看法、教授在课程中的角色以及他们未来在巴西的专业实践。定量数据总结为均值和标准差,并使用学生t检验进行统计分析,P<0.05。定性数据采用内容分析法进行分析。结果显示,私立学校的学生在理论课程对专业实践的贡献程度、所讨论主题的激励水平以及课程与临床实践的相关程度方面,比公立学校的学生有更积极的看法。两组都提到了学习中临床部分的重要性,并认为教授对牙科学生的专业培养投入甚少。学生们对自己准备好在巴西不同社区工作以及与不同社会阶层打交道的看法差异很大。定性分析证实了学生对学习的不满。公立学校和私立学校的学生在评估自己进入就业市场的准备程度方面没有差异。这些发现表明,巴西应采取措施提高教学质量和牙科专业学生的满意度。