Wisler Jon, Khoury Philip R, Kimball Thomas R
University of Cincinnati College of Medicine, Cincinnati, Ohio, USA.
J Am Soc Echocardiogr. 2008 May;21(5):464-9. doi: 10.1016/j.echo.2007.09.003. Epub 2007 Oct 25.
Outcome status in patients with hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) is partially dependent on right ventricular (RV) systolic function. In other disease states, ventricular function is impacted by anatomy and physiology of the contralateral ventricle. In HLHS, it is suggested that a relatively larger left ventricular (LV) size may negatively impact RV function because it becomes a "passenger" without providing any systolic or diastolic physiologic benefit. The purpose of this study was to determine whether LV size adversely affects RV systolic function in surviving patients with HLHS.
The hospital database was searched for all patients with HLHS and technically adequate echocardiograms born in the last 6 years and who had survived at least the Norwood procedure. LV size was assessed by echocardiographic measurement of LV end-diastolic short-axis and apical area. RV function was assessed by short-axis and apical fractional area change as well as the myocardial performance index (Tei). Measurements were made at up to 4 time points depending on duration of follow-up (1 - pre-Norwood; 2 - pre-Glenn; 3 - pre-Fontan; and 4- post-Fontan).
A total of 48 patients were studied. LV size showed sufficient variability in the patient population (1.0-21 cm(2)/body surface area, pre-Norwood). RV function tended to worsen across the time periods but these changes did not reach statistical significance. Regression analysis showed no effect of LV size on RV function before Norwood operation. Significant correlations existed between LV size indices and RV functional indices before Glenn shunt but these were inconsistent in the direction of their effect. Only before Fontan operation did the correlation between LV size and RV function become both consistent and statistically significant; specifically larger LV size correlated significantly with poor RV systolic function (short-axis RV fractional area change vs LV area r = -0.4, P = .03 and RV Tei vs LV area r = 0.5, P = .02). These relationships were not apparent after Fontan operation.
In surviving patients with HLHS, larger LV size does not seem to negatively impact RV function before or after Norwood procedure nor does it seem to have an adverse effect on RV function chronically (after Fontan). However, further study with larger population size will be necessary to see whether these findings remain negative and are true for nonsurvivors as well.
左心发育不全综合征(HLHS)患者的预后状况部分取决于右心室(RV)的收缩功能。在其他疾病状态下,心室功能会受到对侧心室的解剖结构和生理功能的影响。在HLHS中,有人认为相对较大的左心室(LV)尺寸可能会对RV功能产生负面影响,因为它成为一个“乘客”,而不提供任何收缩期或舒张期的生理益处。本研究的目的是确定LV尺寸是否会对存活的HLHS患者的RV收缩功能产生不利影响。
在医院数据库中搜索过去6年出生且至少存活至诺伍德手术的所有HLHS患者以及技术上足够的超声心动图。通过超声心动图测量LV舒张末期短轴和心尖面积来评估LV尺寸。通过短轴和心尖分数面积变化以及心肌性能指数(Tei)来评估RV功能。根据随访时间,最多在4个时间点进行测量(1 - 诺伍德手术前;2 - 格林分流术前;3 - 方坦手术前;4 - 方坦手术后)。
共研究了48例患者。LV尺寸在患者群体中显示出足够的变异性(诺伍德手术前为1.0 - 21 cm²/体表面积)。RV功能在各时间段有恶化趋势,但这些变化未达到统计学意义。回归分析显示诺伍德手术前LV尺寸对RV功能无影响。在格林分流术前,LV尺寸指数与RV功能指数之间存在显著相关性,但它们的影响方向不一致。仅在方坦手术前,LV尺寸与RV功能之间的相关性才变得一致且具有统计学意义;具体而言,较大的LV尺寸与较差的RV收缩功能显著相关(RV短轴分数面积变化与LV面积r = -0.4,P = 0.03;RV Tei与LV面积r = 0.5,P = 0.02)。这些关系在方坦手术后并不明显。
在存活的HLHS患者中,较大的LV尺寸在诺伍德手术前后似乎都不会对RV功能产生负面影响,长期来看(方坦手术后)似乎也不会对RV功能产生不利影响。然而,需要进行更大规模人群的进一步研究,以确定这些发现是否仍然为阴性,以及对非存活者是否也成立。