Pitche Palokinam T, Onipoh Dodji K, Tchangai-Walla Kissem L
Département de médecine et spécialités médicales, Faculté mixte de médecine et de pharmacie, Service de dermatologie, CHU Tokoin, Université de Lomé, BP 81056, Lomé, Togo.
Sante. 2007 Apr-Jun;17(2):117-20.
The medicine dissertation is often the last step of a physician's medical studies. Long considered a rite of passage, it is now regarded as a scientific work deserving attention from the national and international scientific community. The objectives of this study were to document the means by which dissertations at the University of Lomé Medical School are diffused and to determine their impact on the scientific production of medical school faculty.
This cross-sectional study included all dissertations in medicine at the University of Lomé from 1993 through 2002. We interviewed dissertation supervisors and co-supervisors (questionnaire-structured interviews) and consulted the Medline and CNRS/PASCAL databases, scientific communication registers and local journals to collect information.
During this period, 240 dissertations were defended at the University of Lomé medical school. More than half came from the departments of medicine (n=85, 35.4%), surgery (n=57, 23.7%) and paediatrics (n=51, 22.5%). The majority dealt with epidemiological (47 %) and clinical (35.8 %) themes, and only a small minority concerned topics in microbiology and biochemistry (7.5 %). Ninety-nine dissertations (41 %) were published: 54 (22.5%) in indexed journals and 45 (18.5 %) in non-indexed journals; 130 (54%) were delivered as papers or posters at scientific meetings. The distribution of published dissertations according to department showed that the departments of paediatrics (51.3 %), medicine (21.2 %) and surgery (21 %) had the best rates of publication in indexed journals, compared with obstetrics and gynaecology (4 %) and basic science (13.8 %) departments. During the study period, faculty at the University of Lomé medical school published 264 articles in indexed journals: dissertations accounted for only 20.4 %. Dissertations made up a higher proportion of publications in the paediatrics department (32.2 %) than in surgery (20.7 %), medicine (19.8 %), basis sciences (14 %) or obstetrics and gynaecology (3.6 %).
Our study shows that the proportion of published dissertations remains small and is even smaller if we consider only those published in indexed journals (22.5 %). Dissertations also account for an insignificant proportion of the publications by medical school faculty. This raises the question of the scientific interest that the faculty accord to these dissertations.
医学博士论文通常是医生医学学习的最后一步。长期以来,它一直被视为一种必经仪式,而现在则被视为一项值得国内外科学界关注的科学成果。本研究的目的是记录洛美大学医学院博士论文的传播方式,并确定其对医学院教师科研成果的影响。
这项横断面研究涵盖了1993年至2002年洛美大学所有医学博士论文。我们采访了论文导师和联合导师(采用结构化问卷访谈),并查阅了Medline和CNRS/PASCAL数据库、科学交流记录以及当地期刊以收集信息。
在此期间,洛美大学医学院有240篇博士论文通过答辩。一半以上来自医学系(n = 85,35.4%)、外科系(n = 57,23.7%)和儿科系(n = 51,22.5%)。大多数论文涉及流行病学(47%)和临床(35.8%)主题,只有一小部分涉及微生物学和生物化学主题(7.5%)。99篇论文(41%)得以发表:54篇(22.5%)发表在索引期刊上,45篇(18.5%)发表在非索引期刊上;130篇(54%)在科学会议上以论文或海报形式展示。按系别划分的已发表论文分布情况显示,儿科系(51.3%)、医学系(21.2%)和外科系(21%)在索引期刊上的发表率最高,相比之下,妇产科系(4%)和基础科学系(13.8%)较低。在研究期间,洛美大学医学院教师在索引期刊上发表了264篇文章:博士论文仅占20.4%。博士论文在儿科系发表的文章中所占比例(32.2%)高于外科系(20.7%)、医学系(19.8%)、基础科学系(14%)或妇产科系(3.6%)。
我们的研究表明,已发表的博士论文比例仍然较小,如果只考虑在索引期刊上发表的论文,比例则更小(22.5%)。博士论文在医学院教师的出版物中所占比例也微不足道。这就引发了教师对这些博士论文的科学关注度的问题。