Petersen Karin Lottrup, Meadoff Thomas, Press Scott, Peters Michelle M, LeComte Matthew D, Rowbotham Michael C
UCSF Pain Clinical Research Center, Department of Neurology, University of San Francisco, CA, USA Ernest Gallo Clinic and Research Center, Department of Neurology, University of California, San Francisco, CA, USA.
Pain. 2008 Jul 15;137(2):395-404. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2007.09.019. Epub 2007 Oct 30.
Tolerance to the anti-nociceptive effects of opioids develops rapidly in animals. In contrast, humans with chronic pain show little or no loss of pain relief in prospective opioid trials of 4-8 weeks duration. Employing the Brief Thermal Sensitization model to induce transient cutaneous secondary hyperalgesia, we tested the hypothesis that opioid analgesic tolerance would develop rapidly. In this outpatient randomized placebo-controlled study, subjects in the MMMMP group received two injections of subcutaneous morphine 6 mg (150 min apart) on Monday-Thursday (total 48 mg over 4 days) and matching saline placebo on Friday. Subjects in the PPPPM group received placebo on Monday-Thursday and morphine (total 12 mg) on Friday. Sixty-one healthy volunteers were enrolled; morphine side effects accounted for all nine non-completions. Compared to the first placebo day, the reduction in the area of secondary hyperalgesia on the first morphine day was significant and robust in both groups. Morphine suppression of the painfulness of skin heating and elevation of the heat pain detection threshold were also significant. During 4 days of twice-daily injections, the decline in anti-hyperalgesic effects of morphine did not reach statistical significance (p=0.06) compared to placebo. Morphine side effects did not correlate with anti-hyperalgesic effects and withdrawal symptoms did not emerge. As 4 days is the threshold for demonstrating analgesic tolerance to twice-daily morphine in animal models, a longer period of opioid exposure in healthy volunteers might be needed to detect analgesic tolerance.
动物对阿片类药物的抗伤害感受作用很快就会产生耐受性。相比之下,在为期4 - 8周的前瞻性阿片类药物试验中,患有慢性疼痛的人类几乎没有或完全没有失去疼痛缓解效果。我们采用短暂热致敏模型诱导短暂性皮肤继发性痛觉过敏,来检验阿片类镇痛耐受性是否会快速产生这一假设。在这项门诊随机安慰剂对照研究中,MMMMP组的受试者在周一至周四接受两次皮下注射6毫克吗啡(间隔150分钟)(4天共48毫克),周五注射匹配的生理盐水安慰剂。PPPPM组的受试者在周一至周四接受安慰剂,周五接受吗啡(共12毫克)。招募了61名健康志愿者;所有9例未完成试验者均是因吗啡的副作用。与第一个安慰剂日相比,两组在第一个吗啡日时继发性痛觉过敏面积的减少都很显著且明显。吗啡对皮肤加热疼痛的抑制以及热痛检测阈值的提高也很显著。在每日注射两次共4天的期间内,与安慰剂相比,吗啡抗痛觉过敏作用的下降未达到统计学显著性(p = 0.06)。吗啡的副作用与抗痛觉过敏作用不相关,且未出现戒断症状。由于在动物模型中,4天是证明对每日两次吗啡产生镇痛耐受性的阈值,可能需要让健康志愿者更长时间暴露于阿片类药物才能检测到镇痛耐受性。