Simmonds Lesley, Coomber Ross
School of Law and Social Science, University of Plymouth, Drake Circus, Plymouth PL48AA, United Kingdom.
Int J Drug Policy. 2009 Mar;20(2):121-30. doi: 10.1016/j.drugpo.2007.09.002. Epub 2007 Nov 5.
This paper considers the way that social stigma impacts both on injecting drug user (IDU) populations and operates within them and the consequences this has for prevention and harm reduction amongst IDUs.
The research from which this paper is drawn was a city case study, itself part of a larger national study to evaluate the efficacy of needle exchanges throughout England and Wales. Not initially part of the issues being explored, the interviews consistently pointed to concerns of stigma, and in this sense the theme was emergent from the qualitative process itself.
The primary findings relating to this issue were: IDUs concern for being recognised or 'seen' as IDUs affected service uptake and/or their interaction with services; 'normal' IDUs moreover tended to stigmatise those IDUs they believed to be 'worse' than them--primarily the homeless--despite the fact that their own behaviour was often less than 'responsible' itself. In these ways 'stigma', whether being accepted or expressed by these different groups militated against the 'harm reductive' goals of Safer Injecting Services.
It is concluded that much can be done to reduce stigma related to IDU and drug use in general and that this may result in improved service efficacy and a reduction in associated drug related harms. It is also concluded that many IDUs seek to enhance their own self-esteem and reinforce their own sense as 'responsible members of society' rather than the outsiders they often feel themselves to be by attributing stigmatised behaviours on other 'lesser' IDUs. This practice may also contribute to them militating against their own guilt regarding their own risky behaviours, however in so doing the goal of harm reduction may be further undermined.
本文探讨了社会污名对注射吸毒者群体的影响方式、在该群体中的作用机制以及这对注射吸毒者预防和减少伤害工作所产生的后果。
本文所依据的研究是一项城市案例研究,该研究本身是一项更大规模的全国性研究的一部分,旨在评估英格兰和威尔士各地针头交换项目的成效。访谈最初并非所探讨问题的一部分,但始终指向了对污名的担忧,从这个意义上说,该主题是从定性研究过程中自然浮现出来的。
与该问题相关的主要研究发现如下:注射吸毒者担心被认出或被视为注射吸毒者,这影响了他们对服务的接受程度和/或他们与服务机构的互动;此外,“正常”的注射吸毒者往往会污名化那些他们认为比自己“更糟糕”的注射吸毒者——主要是无家可归者——尽管他们自己的行为往往也缺乏“责任感”。通过这些方式,“污名”,无论被这些不同群体接受还是表达出来,都对更安全注射服务的“减少伤害”目标产生了不利影响。
研究得出的结论是,可以采取很多措施来减少与注射吸毒者及一般吸毒行为相关的污名,这可能会提高服务成效,并减少相关的毒品危害。研究还得出结论,许多注射吸毒者试图通过将污名化行为归咎于其他“更差”的注射吸毒者来提升自己的自尊,并强化自己作为“有责任感的社会成员”的意识,而不是他们常常感觉自己所处的局外人身份。这种做法可能也有助于他们减轻对自身危险行为的内疚感,然而这样做可能会进一步破坏减少伤害的目标。