Demange L, De Moncuit C, Thomas G, Olschwang S
Centre René-Huguenin, Saint-Cloud, France.
Rev Neurol (Paris). 2007 Nov;163(11):1031-8. doi: 10.1016/s0035-3787(07)74175-9.
Germline mutations in the NF2 gene are responsible for 80 p.cent of neurofibromatosis type 2 typical cases. Mutations are mainly truncating mutations or deletions, missense mutations having been reported in few cases. An important phenotypic variability is observed among gene carriers. To assess whether the phenotypic variability of neurofibromatosis 2 could be linked to genotype, clinical data of 154 patients whose NF2 germline alteration had been identified in our laboratory have been collected.
A retrospective questionnaire was sent to the physicians in charge of these patients. Statistical analyses regarding genotypic and phenotypic data were performed by comparisons of average values and correlation tests.
In French patients, type of mutation was correlated neither with patients' sex, nor with disease occurrence mode (de novo or inherited mutation). Disease associated with missense mutations occurred later, with a less severe symptomatology. Patients with nonsense or frameshift mutations were more frequently affected with meningiomas and spinal tumours, in addition to VIII nerve schwannomas, an observation that underlies the genetic determination of the number and type of NF2-related tumours.
Results from the literature as well as from our study tend to show that only few correlations exist between genotype and phenotype in the NF2 disease. It also recognizes that missense mutations have a lower level of evolution, severity and mortality risk. Nonsense and frameshift mutations seem to be associated with a higher number of meningiomas and spinal tumours. Therefore, NF2 gene screening keeps its indications in both typical and moderate forms of the disease. Mutations are responsible of 80 p.cent of typical forms; in moderate forms, identification of a missense mutation seems linked to a lower disease evolution. In any case, assessment and supervision should be identical. Finally, in a small number of cases, the NF2 gene appears to be implicated in clinical forms different from those defined by NIH and it might be of interest to enlarge the clinical features suggestive of the disease.
NF2基因的种系突变导致了80%的2型神经纤维瘤病典型病例。突变主要是截短突变或缺失,错义突变仅在少数病例中被报道。在基因携带者中观察到重要的表型变异性。为了评估2型神经纤维瘤病的表型变异性是否与基因型相关,我们收集了在我们实验室中已鉴定出NF2种系改变的154例患者的临床数据。
向负责这些患者的医生发送了一份回顾性调查问卷。通过平均值比较和相关性测试对基因型和表型数据进行统计分析。
在法国患者中,突变类型与患者性别以及疾病发生模式(新发或遗传突变)均无相关性。与错义突变相关的疾病发生较晚,症状较轻。除了第八对脑神经鞘瘤外,无义或移码突变的患者更常患脑膜瘤和脊柱肿瘤,这一观察结果为NF2相关肿瘤的数量和类型的遗传决定提供了依据。
文献以及我们研究的结果倾向于表明,在NF2疾病中基因型与表型之间仅存在少数相关性。研究还认识到错义突变的进展、严重程度和死亡风险较低。无义和移码突变似乎与更多的脑膜瘤和脊柱肿瘤相关。因此,NF2基因筛查在该疾病的典型和中度形式中均保持其适应证。突变导致80%的典型形式;在中度形式中,错义突变的鉴定似乎与较低的疾病进展相关。无论如何,评估和监测应该相同。最后,在少数病例中,NF2基因似乎与美国国立卫生研究院定义的临床形式不同的临床形式有关,扩大提示该疾病的临床特征可能会有意义。