Turner-Stokes Lynne, Ashford Stephen
Regional Rehabilitation Unit, Northwick Park Hospital, Middlesex, UK.
Disabil Rehabil. 2007 Dec 15;29(23):1806-12. doi: 10.1080/09638280701568205.
Three-dimensional movement in the upper limb presents a challenge for functional management of regional spasticity. Potential toxicity of botulinum toxin limits the number of muscles which may be injected in any one session. Serial injection may offer a solution, but carries theoretical risk of development of resistance due to antibody formation. This article reviews a small case series, gathered in a post-acute neuro-rehabilitation setting, to evaluate the use of serial botulinum toxin injection in terms of goal achievement and clinical evidence for toxicity or resistance.
Nine patients with regional spasticity following acute stroke or brain injury had serial injection of botulinum toxin to muscle groups around the shoulder, elbow and/or wrist. Injection was followed by splinting/physiotherapy as appropriate. Goal attainment scaling was used to assess outcome.
Functional goals achieved were reduction of pain (n=6/7) associated reaction (n=4/5) or care needs (n=5/6), improved gait (n=2/3) or independence in self-care (n=2/5). Two 'golden responder' cases are presented in detail to demonstrate resolution of symptoms with up to four serial injections of botulinum toxin over a period of up to 6 months. No clinical evidence of toxicity or resistance was seen in any case.
These preliminary findings suggest that serial botulinum toxin injection followed by appropriate physiotherapy/splinting may provide effective treatment for regional spasticity. Resistance has not presented a problem in this post-acute situation, where treatment has not been required beyond a few months. Ongoing evaluation is underway.
上肢的三维运动给局部痉挛的功能管理带来了挑战。肉毒杆菌毒素的潜在毒性限制了单次注射可累及的肌肉数量。连续注射可能是一种解决方案,但理论上存在因抗体形成而产生耐药性的风险。本文回顾了在急性后神经康复环境中收集的一个小病例系列,以评估连续注射肉毒杆菌毒素在目标达成以及毒性或耐药性临床证据方面的应用情况。
9例急性中风或脑损伤后出现局部痉挛的患者接受了肉毒杆菌毒素对肩部、肘部和/或腕部周围肌肉群的连续注射。注射后酌情进行夹板固定/物理治疗。采用目标达成量表评估结果。
实现的功能目标包括疼痛减轻(6/7)、关联反应减轻(4/5)或护理需求减少(5/6)、步态改善(2/3)或自理能力提高(2/5)。详细介绍了2例“黄金反应者”病例,以展示在长达6个月的时间内进行多达4次肉毒杆菌毒素连续注射后症状的缓解情况。在任何病例中均未发现毒性或耐药性的临床证据。
这些初步研究结果表明,肉毒杆菌毒素连续注射后进行适当的物理治疗/夹板固定可能为局部痉挛提供有效的治疗方法。在这种急性后期情况下,耐药性尚未成为问题,因为治疗时间不超过几个月。正在进行持续评估。