Murphy G K
Department of Pathology, Miami Valley Hospital, Dayton, Ohio.
Am J Forensic Med Pathol. 1991 Dec;12(4):344-9. doi: 10.1097/00000433-199112000-00015.
Determination of time of death (postmortem interval) is one of the most difficult problems confronting forensic pathologists. One noteworthy such case is that of Steven Truscott, a 14-year-old Canadian youth who was convicted of the June 1959 rape-murder of 12-year-old Lynne Harper in rural southwestern Ontario. The two had been seen together on the evening when Lynne was last seen alive. At her autopsy approximately 48 h later, the prosecutor, relying almost entirely on examination of the gastric contents, placed the time of death during the period in which the two were apparently in each other's company. Truscott's defense was unable to refute this opinion, and Truscott was sentenced first to death, then to life imprisonment. Isabel LeBourdais, a Canadian journalist, published a book defending Truscott that eventually led to a judicial rehearing, but his conviction was upheld. The examination of gastric contents is only one measure employed in the often difficult determination of time of death. It has not been made inherently more reliable in this regard since 1959. It is crucial, therefore, to use all available evidence in determining time of death.
确定死亡时间(死后间隔时间)是法医病理学家面临的最困难问题之一。一个值得注意的案例是史蒂文·特鲁斯科特案,他是一名14岁的加拿大青年,被判定于1959年6月在安大略省西南部农村强奸并谋杀了12岁的琳恩·哈珀。琳恩最后一次被看到还活着的那个晚上,有人看到他们两人在一起。大约48小时后对琳恩进行尸检时,检察官几乎完全依据对胃内容物的检查,将死亡时间确定在两人显然在一起的那段时间。特鲁斯科特的辩护方无法反驳这一观点,特鲁斯科特先是被判处死刑,后改为终身监禁。加拿大记者伊莎贝尔·勒布尔代斯出版了一本书为特鲁斯科特辩护,最终导致了一次司法重审,但他的有罪判决维持不变。胃内容物检查只是在通常很困难的死亡时间确定过程中采用的一种方法。自1959年以来,在这方面它并没有本质上变得更可靠。因此,在确定死亡时间时使用所有可用证据至关重要。