Borasio Piero, Berruti Alfredo, Billé Andrea, Lausi Paolo, Levra Matteo Giaj, Giardino Roberto, Ardissone Francesco
University of Turin, Department of Clinical & Biological Sciences, Thoracic Surgery Unit, Italy.
Eur J Cardiothorac Surg. 2008 Feb;33(2):307-13. doi: 10.1016/j.ejcts.2007.09.044.
Treatment of malignant pleural mesothelioma (MPM) remains disappointing, although recent reports suggest that multimodality therapy including surgery may provide a significant survival benefit. The aims of this single institution study were: to investigate clinicopathologic characteristics and potential prognostic factors in MPM patients, and to ascertain whether surgery followed by adjuvant therapy had an independent prognostic role.
Retrospective review of a prospectively compiled computerized database of all patients with MPM evaluated between 1989 and 2003. Kaplan-Meier method, log-rank test, and Cox model were used in the statistical analysis.
There were 394 patients: 270 men (68.5%), 124 women, median age 64 (range 28-93). Twenty-seven patients (6.8%) underwent surgical resection (extrapleural pneumonectomy 15, pleurectomy/decortication 12), followed by adjuvant therapy. As of March 2006, 381 patients (96.7%) had died (median survival, 11.7 months; range 0.03-117.9). Median follow-up of 13 surviving patients (3.3%) was 45.2 months (range 28.7-126.5). Overall survival at 2 years was 18.8%. Multimodality therapy including surgery yielded a median survival of 14.5 months and a 2-year survival rate of 29.6%. Using univariate analysis, age (p=0.009), chest pain (p=0.01), weight loss (p=0.001), performance status (p=0.0001), platelet count (p=0.008), histology (p=0.0001), macroscopic appearance of pleural surface (non-specific inflammation, tumor-like thickening, or nodules; p=0.0001), visceral pleura involvement (p=0.0001), degree of involvement of pleural cavity (less than or more than one third of the cavity; p=0.0001), and multimodality therapy (p<0.01) were found to be significant prognostic factors. At multivariate analysis, performance status, platelet count, histology, and degree of involvement of pleural cavity remained independently associated with survival, whereas multimodality therapy failed to enter the model.
Significant predictors of survival include performance status, platelet count, histology, and degree of involvement of pleural cavity. Within the confines of this retrospective study and the small number of patients undergoing multimodality therapy, the role of surgery in the treatment of MPM remains unclear. Further investigation is warranted to determine the optimal treatment strategy in this disease.
恶性胸膜间皮瘤(MPM)的治疗效果仍然不尽人意,尽管最近的报告表明包括手术在内的多模式治疗可能带来显著的生存获益。本单中心研究的目的是:调查MPM患者的临床病理特征和潜在预后因素,并确定手术加辅助治疗是否具有独立的预后作用。
回顾性分析1989年至2003年间所有接受评估的MPM患者的前瞻性编制计算机数据库。统计分析采用Kaplan-Meier法、对数秩检验和Cox模型。
共有394例患者:男性270例(68.5%),女性124例,中位年龄64岁(范围28 - 93岁)。27例患者(6.8%)接受了手术切除(15例行胸膜外全肺切除术,12例行胸膜切除术/剥脱术),随后接受辅助治疗。截至2006年3月,381例患者(96.7%)死亡(中位生存期11.7个月;范围0.03 - 117.9个月)。13例存活患者(3.3%)的中位随访时间为45.2个月(范围28.7 - 126.5个月)。2年总生存率为18.8%。包括手术在内的多模式治疗的中位生存期为14.5个月,2年生存率为29.6%。单因素分析显示,年龄(p = 0.009)、胸痛(p = 0.01)、体重减轻(p = 0.001)、体能状态(p = 0.0001)、血小板计数(p = 0.008)、组织学类型(p = 0.0001)、胸膜表面宏观表现(非特异性炎症、肿瘤样增厚或结节;p = 0.0001)、脏层胸膜受累情况(p = 0.0001)、胸腔受累程度(小于或大于胸腔的三分之一;p = 0.0001)以及多模式治疗(p < 0.01)是显著的预后因素。多因素分析显示,体能状态、血小板计数、组织学类型和胸腔受累程度仍与生存独立相关,而多模式治疗未能纳入模型。
生存的显著预测因素包括体能状态、血小板计数、组织学类型和胸腔受累程度。在这项回顾性研究以及接受多模式治疗的患者数量较少的情况下,手术在MPM治疗中的作用仍不明确。有必要进一步研究以确定该疾病的最佳治疗策略。