Conrad Ansgar, Isaac Linda, Roth Walton T
Department of Psychiatry and Behavioral Sciences, Stanford University School of Medicine, and the Veterans Affairs Health Care System, Palo Alto, California, USA.
Psychophysiology. 2008 May;45(3):366-76. doi: 10.1111/j.1469-8986.2007.00601.x. Epub 2008 Jan 23.
Generalized anxiety disorder (GAD) patients have been reported to have more muscle tension than controls, which has provided a rationale for treating them with muscle relaxation therapies (MRT). We tested this rationale by comparing 49 GAD patients with 21 controls. Participants underwent 5-min relaxation tests, during which they either just sat quietly (QS) or sat quietly and tried to relax (R). GAD patients reported themselves to be more worried during the assessment than the controls, had higher heart rates and lower end-tidal pCO2, but not higher muscle tension as measured by multiple EMGs. QS and R did not differ on most psychological and physiological measures, indicating that intention to relax did not affect speed of relaxation. In the GAD group, self-reported anxiety was not associated with electromyographic or autonomic measures. We conclude that GAD is not necessarily characterized by chronic muscle tension, and that this rationale for MRT should be reconsidered.
据报道,广泛性焦虑症(GAD)患者比对照组有更多的肌肉紧张,这为用肌肉放松疗法(MRT)治疗他们提供了理论依据。我们通过比较49名GAD患者和21名对照组来验证这一理论依据。参与者接受了5分钟的放松测试,在此期间,他们要么只是安静地坐着(QS),要么安静地坐着并试图放松(R)。GAD患者报告称,在评估期间他们比对照组更焦虑,心率更高,呼气末二氧化碳分压更低,但通过多个肌电图测量的肌肉紧张程度并不更高。QS和R在大多数心理和生理指标上没有差异,这表明放松的意图并不影响放松速度。在GAD组中,自我报告的焦虑与肌电图或自主神经指标无关。我们得出结论,GAD不一定以慢性肌肉紧张为特征,MRT的这一理论依据应重新考虑。