Chandrasekar Thenappan, Sharan Ashwini D, Sperling Michael R
Comprehensive Epilepsy Center, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, PA, United States.
Epilepsy Res. 2008 Feb;78(2-3):195-200. doi: 10.1016/j.eplepsyres.2007.12.004. Epub 2008 Jan 24.
Little is known about the prognostic significance of persistent auras following temporal lobe surgery in determining the recurrence of complex partial seizures (CPS) or generalized tonic-clonic seizures (GTCS).
In a retrospective analysis of temporal lobectomy patients who had preoperative auras associated with CPS or GTCS and who were seizure-free following surgery, the predictive value of auras was assessed at 3 months and 2 years following surgery. Medication use, in relation to the presence of auras, was also assessed.
Three hundred and forty-seven patients were seizure-free for 3 months following surgery (247 aura-free, 101 with persistent auras). KM analysis yielded no difference in outcome (p=0.65) and current outcome class was also similar (p=0.99). Patients with persistent auras were somewhat more likely to be on medication at the time of recurrence (p=0.06) and at last follow-up (p=0.09). 224 patients were seizure-free for 2 years following surgery (163 aura-free, 61 with persistent auras). KM analysis yielded no difference in outcome (p=0.86) and current outcome class was also similar (p=0.35). Patients with persistent auras were more likely to be on medication at the time of recurrence (p<0.001) and at last contact (p<0.01).
Auras were not associated with increased risk of recurrence, although increased rates of AED use were seen in these patients. However, any medication effect appears to be quite small, so we consider it reasonable to advise cessation of AEDs in patients with persistent auras who are otherwise seizure-free.
关于颞叶手术后持续性先兆在确定复杂部分性发作(CPS)或全身强直 - 阵挛性发作(GTCS)复发方面的预后意义,目前所知甚少。
在一项对术前有与CPS或GTCS相关先兆且术后无癫痫发作的颞叶切除术患者的回顾性分析中,评估了术后3个月和2年时先兆的预测价值。还评估了与先兆存在相关的药物使用情况。
347例患者术后3个月无癫痫发作(247例无先兆,101例有持续性先兆)。Kaplan - Meier分析显示结局无差异(p = 0.65),当前结局类别也相似(p = 0.99)。有持续性先兆的患者在复发时(p = 0.06)和最后一次随访时(p = 0.09)使用药物的可能性略高。224例患者术后2年无癫痫发作(163例无先兆,61例有持续性先兆)。Kaplan - Meier分析显示结局无差异(p = 0.86),当前结局类别也相似(p = 0.35)。有持续性先兆的患者在复发时(p < 0.001)和最后一次联系时(p < 0.01)使用药物的可能性更高。
先兆与复发风险增加无关,尽管这些患者中抗癫痫药物(AED)的使用率有所增加。然而,任何药物作用似乎都相当小,因此我们认为建议在其他方面无癫痫发作的有持续性先兆的患者中停用AED是合理的。