Green Joseph P, Lynn Steven Jay, Montgomery Guy H
The Ohio State University, 4240 Campus Drive Lima, OH 45804, USA.
Am J Clin Hypn. 2008 Jan;50(3):259-71. doi: 10.1080/00029157.2008.10401628.
In an earlier meta-analysis of 12 studies using hypnosis-based treatments for smoking cessation, we provided preliminary evidence that males fare better than females when trying to quit smoking (Green, Lynn, & Montgomery, 2006). By excluding studies that reported no gender differences, but failed to report final outcome-statistics-by-gender, our previous conclusion may have overestimated the role of gender in hypnosis-based smoking cessation treatment. In the present analysis, we included 12 additional studies that reported no gender differences, but failed to report final outcome-by-gender statistics. Across each of these studies, we calculated identical success rates for male and female participants and then added these results to our database. Among all 24 groups of participants who completed hypnosis-based treatment for smoking, we found a small but significant effect for male participants being more successful in quitting smoking relative to females. Specific suggestions for tailoring hypnosis smoking cessation programs to take gender differences into account are discussed.
在一项早期对12项使用基于催眠的治疗方法戒烟的研究的荟萃分析中,我们提供了初步证据,表明男性在试图戒烟时比女性表现更好(格林、林恩和蒙哥马利,2006年)。通过排除那些报告无性别差异但未按性别报告最终结果统计数据的研究,我们之前的结论可能高估了性别在基于催眠的戒烟治疗中的作用。在本分析中,我们纳入了另外12项报告无性别差异但未按性别报告最终结果统计数据的研究。在这些研究中的每一项中,我们计算了男性和女性参与者相同的成功率,然后将这些结果添加到我们的数据库中。在所有24组完成基于催眠的戒烟治疗的参与者中,我们发现男性参与者相对于女性在戒烟方面更成功,这一效果虽小但显著。我们还讨论了针对考虑性别差异调整催眠戒烟计划的具体建议。