Fletcher Adam, Bonell Chris, Hargreaves James
The Centre for Research on Drugs and Health Behaviour, London School of Hygiene and Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
J Adolesc Health. 2008 Mar;42(3):209-20. doi: 10.1016/j.jadohealth.2007.09.020. Epub 2007 Dec 26.
This systematic review examined the hypothesis that school institutional factors influence young people's use of drugs. We aimed to (1) identify the effect of school-level changes on drug use and (2) explore the possible mechanisms by which school-level influences on individual drug use might occur.
Systematic review. Experimental/quasi-experimental studies of "whole-school" drug prevention interventions and longitudinal observational studies on the association between school-level and individual-level school-related exposures and drug use were included. Experimental studies were included because they are the most reliable available source of evidence about causation. Observational studies of school-level and individual-level school-related exposures were included with the aim of providing evidence about a wider range of possible school-level effects and how school-level influences might be mediated by individual-level factors.
Experimental studies suggested that changes to the school social environment that increase student participation, improve relationships and promote a positive school ethos may be associated with reduced drug use. School-level and individual-level observational studies consistently reported that disengagement and poor teacher-student relationships were associated with drug use and other risky health behaviors.
There is evidence of school effects on young people's drug use. Interventions that promote a positive school ethos and reduce student disaffection may be an effective complement to drug prevention interventions addressing individual knowledge, skills, and peer norms. Such approaches should now be piloted in a wider range of settings. Further research is also needed to explore mechanisms by which schools may influence young people's drug use.
本系统评价检验了学校制度因素影响青少年药物使用这一假设。我们旨在(1)确定学校层面的变化对药物使用的影响,以及(2)探究学校层面影响个体药物使用可能的机制。
系统评价。纳入了关于“全校性”药物预防干预措施的实验性/准实验性研究,以及关于学校层面与个体层面学校相关暴露及药物使用之间关联的纵向观察性研究。纳入实验性研究是因为它们是关于因果关系最可靠的现有证据来源。纳入学校层面和个体层面学校相关暴露的观察性研究,目的是提供关于更广泛的可能学校层面影响以及学校层面影响如何由个体层面因素介导的证据。
实验性研究表明,学校社会环境的变化若能增加学生参与度、改善人际关系并促进积极的学校风气,可能与药物使用减少有关。学校层面和个体层面的观察性研究一致报告称,脱离学校和师生关系不佳与药物使用及其他危险健康行为有关。
有证据表明学校对青少年的药物使用有影响。促进积极学校风气并减少学生不满情绪的干预措施,可能是针对个体知识、技能和同伴规范的药物预防干预措施的有效补充。此类方法现在应在更广泛的环境中进行试点。还需要进一步研究来探索学校可能影响青少年药物使用的机制。