Cusack P M V, McMeniman N P, Lean I J
Australian Livestock Production Services, 102 Darling St, Cowra NSW 2794, Australia.
Aust Vet J. 2008 Mar;86(3):81-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1751-0813.2008.00255.x.
To examine the effects of injectable vitamins A, D and E at feedlot entry on health and growth rate and the effects of injectable vitamin C at the time of treatment for bovine respiratory disease (BRD) on cattle health.
Systematic allocation of 2465 cattle at feedlot entry to: a commercial vitamin A, D and E preparation at the label dose rate; commercial vitamin A, D and E at twice the label dose rate; a formulation with no vitamin D, a lower concentration of vitamin A and a higher concentration of vitamin E; and the oil-based carrier alone at volumes corresponding to the above treatments. Comparisons of growth rate, disease and mortality were made between the groups at the conclusion of the feeding period. In a separate experiment, 176 cattle were alternately administered injectable vitamin C at the time of treatment for BRD, or were not injected with vitamin C, and mortality was compared between the groups.
There were no differences between cattle administered vitamin A, D and E at feedlot entry and the controls in growth rate (P=0.11), all diseases (P=0.99), BRD (P=0.60) or mortalities (P=0.95). Cattle treated with the higher vitamin E and lower vitamin A preparation had a higher (P=0.02) incidence of anorexia than the other groups. Fewer cattle treated with 5 g of vitamin C by intramuscular injection at the time of treatment with antibiotics for BRD subsequently died (P=0.04).
The routine injection of cattle with vitamins A, D and E at feedlot entry is unlikely to result in improvements in health and growth rate where cattle are provided with these vitamins in their diets at concentrations equal to the National Research Council recommendations. Mortality rate in cattle diagnosed with BRD may be reduced by intramuscular injection of vitamin C at the time of treatment with antibiotics.
研究育肥场入栏时注射维生素A、D和E对牛健康及生长速度的影响,以及在治疗牛呼吸道疾病(BRD)时注射维生素C对牛健康的影响。
在育肥场入栏时将2465头牛系统分配至以下组:按标签剂量率使用的市售维生素A、D和E制剂;两倍标签剂量率的市售维生素A、D和E;不含维生素D、维生素A浓度较低且维生素E浓度较高的制剂;以及与上述处理体积相同的仅油基载体。在饲养期结束时比较各组之间的生长速度、疾病和死亡率。在另一项实验中,176头牛在治疗BRD时交替接受注射维生素C或不注射维生素C,并比较两组之间的死亡率。
育肥场入栏时接受维生素A、D和E注射的牛与对照组在生长速度(P = 0.11)、所有疾病(P = 0.99)、BRD(P = 0.60)或死亡率(P = 0.95)方面均无差异。接受较高维生素E和较低维生素A制剂处理的牛厌食发生率高于其他组(P = 0.02)。在使用抗生素治疗BRD时通过肌肉注射5 g维生素C处理的牛随后死亡的较少(P = 0.04)。
在育肥场入栏时对牛常规注射维生素A、D和E,若牛日粮中这些维生素的浓度等于美国国家研究委员会的建议量,则不太可能改善其健康和生长速度。在使用抗生素治疗BRD时通过肌肉注射维生素C可能会降低牛的死亡率。