Cabré Montserrat
History of Science, Facultad de Medicina, Universidad de Cantabria, Cardenal Herrera Oria s/n, Santander, Spain.
Bull Hist Med. 2008 Spring;82(1):18-51. doi: 10.1353/bhm.2008.0040.
Assessments of medieval health care used to focus on practitioners holding some sort of occupational label, resulting in a meager representation of women. This article intends to illustrate how women's significant contribution to healthcare can be mapped out by looking at the domestic space that is largely left outside the histories of medieval medicine. First, it explores the language that names women's activities to maintain health and alleviate illness, showing how words identifying women's capacities to heal come from everyday actions and belong to the semantic domain of women and mothers. The caring meanings ascribed to the words women, mothers, midwives, and nurses in the Iberian mother tongues conflate and describe a continuum of practice whose origin is the household, from where it expands to the community. Second, it discusses the importance of women's ordinary domestic care within the theoretical frame of the six non-naturals, particularly feeding and nourishing, as well as presenting the household as an open and flexible space providing health care beyond the family. Third, by considering recipes as privileged evidence, it attempts to piece together a preliminary textual history of women's household knowledges that for centuries had been circumscribed to the domain of the oral. It identifies the written contexts where women's recipes appear through a long timespan, attesting changes in women's literate practices that give rise to new genres that illuminate a sphere previously opaque to the historical record.
对中世纪医疗保健的评估过去常常聚焦于持有某种职业标签的从业者,这导致女性在研究中所占比例极低。本文旨在说明,通过审视在很大程度上被排除在中世纪医学史之外的家庭空间,可以勾勒出女性对医疗保健的重大贡献。首先,文章探究了用于描述女性维护健康和减轻疾病活动的语言,展示了用于识别女性治疗能力的词汇如何源于日常行为,且属于女性和母亲的语义范畴。伊比利亚母语中赋予“女性”“母亲”“助产士”和“护士”这些词汇的关怀含义相互融合,描绘出了一个连续的实践过程,其起源是家庭,并从家庭扩展到社区。其次,文章讨论了在六种非自然因素的理论框架内,女性日常家庭护理的重要性,特别是喂养和滋养方面,还将家庭呈现为一个开放且灵活的空间,它提供的医疗保健超越了家庭范围。第三,通过将食谱视为重要证据,文章试图拼凑出女性家庭知识的初步文本历史,这些知识几个世纪以来一直局限于口头领域。文章确定了女性食谱在很长一段时间内出现的书面背景,证明了女性识字实践的变化,这些变化产生了新的体裁,照亮了一个此前历史记录难以触及的领域。