Namasivayam Aravind Kumar, van Lieshout Pascal, De Nil Luc
Department of Speech-Language Pathology, University of Toronto, Canada.
J Commun Disord. 2008 Jul-Aug;41(4):372-94. doi: 10.1016/j.jcomdis.2008.02.004. Epub 2008 Mar 2.
This exploratory study investigated sensory-motor mechanisms in five people who stutter (PWS) and five people who do not (PNS). Lip kinematic and coordination data were recorded as they produced bi-syllabic nonwords at two rates (normal and fast) in three conditions (jaw-free, immediately after insertion of a bite-block, and after a 10-min accommodation period). At normal speech rates, effects of bite-blocks on lip kinematics were similar for both PWS and PNS speakers showing larger amplitudes, peak velocities, shorter durations and more stable movement cycle patterns. However, at fast speech rates upper lip responses of PWS exhibited larger amplitudes and peak velocities. At both speech rates, the presence of a bite-block changed movement coordination patterns only for PNS. However, at fast speech rates bite-blocks decreased variability of coordination patterns for both groups. No adaptive changes in movement stability were found for either group, but a practice-related increase in lower lip peak velocity was found at normal speech rates. These findings indicate that bite-block perturbation did not exacerbate any hypothesized limitation or difficulty in controlling individual articulatory movements or their coordination in PWS. The results also support the position that specific motor control strategies are used by PWS as compared to PNS to compensate for bite-block perturbations under increased speech rate demands.
The reader will be able to: (1) distinguish between compensatory and adaptive responses to bite-block perturbation; (2) explain the measurement of articulatory stability; (3) summarize the potential role of motor control strategies in people who stutter; and (4) discuss the assumptions of the motor skills approach to stuttering.
本探索性研究调查了5名口吃者(PWS)和5名非口吃者(PNS)的感觉运动机制。在三种条件下(无下颌运动、插入咬块后立即进行、以及10分钟适应期后),以两种语速(正常语速和快速语速)说出双音节非词时,记录唇部运动学和协调性数据。在正常语速下,咬块对唇部运动学的影响在PWS和PNS说话者中相似,表现为更大的幅度、峰值速度、更短的持续时间和更稳定的运动周期模式。然而,在快速语速下,PWS的上唇反应表现出更大的幅度和峰值速度。在两种语速下,咬块的存在仅改变了PNS的运动协调模式。然而,在快速语速下,咬块降低了两组的协调模式变异性。两组均未发现运动稳定性的适应性变化,但在正常语速下发现了与练习相关的下唇峰值速度增加。这些发现表明,咬块扰动并未加剧PWS在控制单个发音动作或其协调性方面的任何假设限制或困难。结果还支持这样一种观点,即与PNS相比,PWS在语速增加的需求下使用特定的运动控制策略来补偿咬块扰动。
读者将能够:(1)区分对咬块扰动的补偿性和适应性反应;(2)解释发音稳定性的测量;(3)总结运动控制策略在口吃者中的潜在作用;以及(4)讨论口吃运动技能方法的假设。