Macdonald Dusten M, Lin Lillie L, Biehl Kenneth, Mutic Sasa, Nantz Regan, Grigsby Perry W
Department of Radiation Oncology, Mallinckrodt Institute of Radiology, St. Louis, MO 63110, USA.
Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2008 Jun 1;71(2):618-24. doi: 10.1016/j.ijrobp.2008.02.014. Epub 2008 Apr 11.
This treatment planning study compared pseudo-step-wedge intensity modulation (PSWIM), intensity-modulated radiation therapy (IMRT), and conventional external irradiation, all combined with brachytherapy, for treatment of patients with cervical cancer.
This was a prospective study of 10 patients treated with PSWIM delivering 50.4 Gy to the pelvic lymph nodes and 20 Gy to the cervical tumor. This treatment was compared with a conventional treatment plan with a four-field box to 45 Gy and to an IMRT plan delivering 45 Gy. In each case, brachytherapy was prescribed to a total Point A low-dose-rate equivalent dose of 85 Gy. Total doses to Points A, Point P, the bladder point, and the rectal point were calculated. Acute toxicity and treatment response were prospectively recorded.
The mean PSWIM total low-dose-rate equivalent dose to Points A and P (97.3 Gy and 65.1 Gy, respectively) was significantly higher, the mean rectal dose was the same, and the mean bladder dose was higher than with IMRT or four-field box. No acute toxicity of greater Grade 2, as defined by the than Radiation Therapy Oncology Group, was experienced. The positron emission tomography-based treatment response compared favorably with our institutional experience.
Use of PSWIM and brachytherapy delivers significantly more dose to the tumor and lymph nodes than do competing techniques. Rectal doses are comparable. Maximum bladder point doses are higher. Toxicity and tumor response are acceptable.
本治疗计划研究比较了伪阶梯楔形调强放疗(PSWIM)、调强放射治疗(IMRT)和传统外照射,这三种方法均联合近距离放疗用于治疗宫颈癌患者。
这是一项前瞻性研究,对10例接受PSWIM治疗的患者进行研究,PSWIM对盆腔淋巴结给予50.4 Gy照射剂量,对宫颈肿瘤给予20 Gy照射剂量。将该治疗方案与采用四野盒式照射至45 Gy的传统治疗计划以及给予45 Gy照射剂量的IMRT计划进行比较。在每种情况下,近距离放疗的处方剂量为A点总低剂量率等效剂量85 Gy。计算了A点、P点、膀胱点和直肠点的总剂量。前瞻性记录急性毒性和治疗反应。
PSWIM对A点和P点的平均总低剂量率等效剂量(分别为97.3 Gy和65.1 Gy)显著更高,直肠平均剂量相同,膀胱平均剂量高于IMRT或四野盒式照射。未出现大于放射肿瘤学组定义的2级急性毒性反应。基于正电子发射断层扫描的治疗反应与我们机构的经验相比表现良好。
与其他技术相比,使用PSWIM和近距离放疗可向肿瘤和淋巴结输送显著更多的剂量。直肠剂量相当。膀胱点最大剂量更高。毒性和肿瘤反应可接受。