Alves de Lima Alberto E
Instituto Cardiovascular de Buenos Aires.
Medicina (B Aires). 2008;68(1):88-92.
Constructive feedback is defined as the act of giving information to a student or resident through the description of their performance in an observed clinical situation. The following keys are required during feedback in order to get student's performance improvement: the observation of an event, the instructor's comment on said performance, by following always a pre-established pattern or standard, and advice on improvement. Major impact takes place when a student or a resident compares the teacher's feedback to its own performance. The dissonance between desired and actual performance constitutes a strong motivation and deep-learning generator. Most of the teachers find it essential, but in general they carry it out in a short and non specific way. Medical students and residents are willing to get and need constructive feedback and they clearly associate it to high-quality learning. However, even though they appreciate it, they seldom request it. It is essential to take maximum advantage of feedback by giving recommendations, producing reactions and self-analysis and also by defining an appropriate action plan. It takes time and effort to apply this tool, but it is of great value for the growth and academic development of students and residents.
建设性反馈被定义为通过描述学生或住院医师在观察到的临床情境中的表现,向其提供信息的行为。为了提高学生的表现,反馈过程需要以下关键要素:对事件的观察、教师对上述表现的评论(始终遵循预先设定的模式或标准)以及改进建议。当学生或住院医师将教师的反馈与自己的表现进行比较时,会产生重大影响。期望表现与实际表现之间的不一致构成了强大的动力和深度学习的驱动力。大多数教师认为这很重要,但总体而言,他们的反馈方式简短且不具体。医学生和住院医师愿意接受并需要建设性反馈,他们明确将其与高质量学习联系起来。然而,尽管他们对此表示赞赏,但很少主动要求。通过给出建议、产生反应和进行自我分析,并制定适当的行动计划,充分利用反馈至关重要。应用这个工具需要时间和精力,但它对学生和住院医师的成长及学术发展具有巨大价值。