Régis J, Arkha Y, Yomo S, Bartolomei F, Peragut J-C, Chauvel P
Service de neurochirurgie fonctionnelle et stéréotaxique, hôpital de La Timone, boulevard Jean-Moulin, 13385 Marseille cedex 5, France.
Neurochirurgie. 2008 May;54(3):320-31. doi: 10.1016/j.neuchi.2008.02.016. Epub 2008 Apr 15.
There is growing interest in the use of radiosurgery in epilepsy. We analyzed our experience in this field in an attempt to define the potential of radiosurgery in epileptology.
[corrected] Our local clinical experience (134 patients), accumulated over the last 15 years, mainly includes treatment of temporal lobe epilepsy without space-occupying lesions (59 patients), including 53 with pure MTLE, 61 cases of hypothalamic hamartoma, two cases of callosotomy, and 12 other types of epilepsy.
The analysis of our material, as well as other clinical and experimental data, suggest that the use of radiosurgery is beneficial only to patients in whom a strict preoperative definition of the extent of the epileptogenic zone (or network) has been achieved and strict rules of dose planning have been applied. As soon as these principles are not observed, the risk of treatment failure and/or side effects increases dramatically. Long-term outcome data are now available and published for MTLE but not yet for other types of epilepsy. Long-term safety and efficacy in MTLE are comparable to surgical resection but radiosurgery has the advantage of sparing verbal memory in patients operated by Gamma Knife (GK) on the dominant side. In small hamartomas, the efficacy is comparable to microsurgery but with a dramatic reduction in risk.
The vast amount of clinical materiel and long-term evaluation now support the use of GK surgery in small hypothalamic hamartomas and MTLE when the patient is at risk of verbal memory loss.
放射外科在癫痫治疗中的应用越来越受到关注。我们分析了我们在该领域的经验,试图确定放射外科在癫痫学中的潜力。
[已校正]我们在过去15年中积累的本地临床经验(134例患者),主要包括对无占位性病变的颞叶癫痫的治疗(59例患者),其中包括53例单纯颞叶内侧癫痫、61例下丘脑错构瘤、2例胼胝体切开术以及12例其他类型的癫痫。
对我们的资料以及其他临床和实验数据的分析表明,只有在术前严格界定致痫区(或网络)范围并应用严格的剂量规划规则的患者中,放射外科的应用才有益。一旦不遵守这些原则,治疗失败和/或副作用的风险就会急剧增加。目前已有颞叶内侧癫痫的长期疗效数据并已发表,但其他类型癫痫的相关数据尚未公布。颞叶内侧癫痫的长期安全性和疗效与手术切除相当,但放射外科在优势侧接受伽玛刀(GK)手术的患者中具有保留言语记忆的优势。在小型错构瘤中,疗效与显微手术相当,但风险显著降低。
大量的临床资料和长期评估现在支持在患者有言语记忆丧失风险的小型下丘脑错构瘤和颞叶内侧癫痫中使用GK手术。