Quadrelli Silvia, Lyons Gustavo, Ciallella Lorena, Iotti Alejandro, Chertcoff Julio
Unidad de Medicina Respiratoria y Servicio de Cirugía Torácica del Hospital Británico de Buenos Aires, Argentina.
Medicina (B Aires). 2007;67(6 Pt 2):691-7.
The objective of this study was to determine the morbidity, mortality and diagnostic yield of video assisted thoracoscopy (VATS) and thoracotomy lung biopsy in interstitial lung disease (ILD). Clinical records of 71 patients were retrospectively analyzed. There was no difference in mean hospital stay, intensive care unit stay and duration of chest tube drainage in patients with VATS (n = 52) compared with those undergoing open thoracotomy (n = 17). Complications rate (22.2% vs. 21.0%, p = 1.0000) and operating mortality (9.2 vs. 15.7%, p = 0.2738) were also similar. Overall, complications occurred in 16 patients (22.5%). Thirty-day mortality rate was 11.2% (n = 8). Prevalence of immunosupression (4/8 vs. 9/63, p = 0.0325) was significantly higher in the group of patients who died. No surviving patients had higher values of plasmatic urea (50 +/- 20.1 mg/dl vs. 31.2 +/- 10.3 mg/dl, p = 0.0013) or lower values of preoperative oxygen saturation (SaO2): 82.7 +/- 14.8% vs. 92.8 +/- 3.4%, (p = 0.0009). Eleven patients had an acute illness. Those patients did not show a higher complication rate (4/11 vs. 10/45, p = 0.4390) but mortality was significantly higher (4/11, 36.3% vs. 3/45, 7.1%, p = 0.0223). Biopsy allowed a specific histologic diagnosis in 100% of patients and changed therapy in 66.7%. We conclude that surgical lung biopsy is a safe and useful procedure in patients with ILD. However the higher mortality rate in patients with acute symptoms, immunocompromise, or in respiratory failure must be balanced against potential benefits of altering treatment decisions.
本研究的目的是确定电视辅助胸腔镜手术(VATS)和开胸肺活检在间质性肺疾病(ILD)中的发病率、死亡率及诊断率。对71例患者的临床记录进行了回顾性分析。接受VATS手术的患者(n = 52)与接受开胸手术的患者(n = 17)相比,平均住院时间、重症监护病房停留时间和胸管引流持续时间并无差异。并发症发生率(22.2% 对 21.0%,p = 1.0000)和手术死亡率(9.2对15.7%,p = 0.2738)也相似。总体而言,16例患者(22.5%)发生了并发症。30天死亡率为11.2%(n = 8)。死亡患者组的免疫抑制患病率(4/8对9/63,p = 0.0325)显著更高。存活患者的血浆尿素值无更高水平(50±20.1mg/dl对31.2±10.3mg/dl,p = 0.0013),术前氧饱和度(SaO2)值也无更低水平:82.7±14.8%对92.8±3.4%,(p = 0.0009)。11例患者患有急性疾病。这些患者的并发症发生率并未更高(4/11对10/45,p = 0.4390),但死亡率显著更高(4/11,36.3%对3/45,7.1%,p = 0.0223)。活检使100%的患者获得了特异性组织学诊断,66.7%的患者治疗方案得以改变。我们得出结论,手术肺活检对于ILD患者是一种安全且有用的操作。然而,急性症状、免疫功能低下或呼吸衰竭患者较高的死亡率必须与改变治疗决策的潜在益处相权衡。