Kerboull L, Christel P, Meunier A
Chirurgie. 1991;117(9):751-62.
Tendon allografts are presently used for surgical reconstruction of the anterior cruciate ligament. The aim of this study was the in vitro evaluation of the modification of the mechanical properties of conserved human patellar tendons, deep-frozen or freeze-dried and sterilized with gamma rays. Thirty pairs of patellar tendons (central third) with their bony attachments were removed from fresh corpses, frozen in liquid nitrogen, then conserved at -80 degrees C. Out of each pair, one tendon was submitted to an additional treatment and the other was used as a control. Three types of treatment were studied: 2.5 Mrad irradiation (groupe I), freeze-drying with 1% residual humidity (groupe II), consecutive freeze-drying and irradiation (group III). After warming up (controls and group I treated tendons), the specimens were submitted to mechanical tests on the pulling machine with a suitable arrangement. Two types of tests were performed: a creep test (80 cycles at 1 Hz between 0 and 50 N) then an ultimate tensile strength test (0.25 mm/s). Freeze-drying causes macroscopic morphological alterations, which are even more marked if irradiation is applied in addition. The three types of treatment induce an increase in creep and a decrease in the ultimate, tensile strength and in Young's module, all being statistically significant. The three types of treatment alter the mechanical properties of the allograft. Freeze-drying maintains a better resistance of the graft. The combination of freeze-drying and irradiation is the most damaging method, and freeze-drying even seems to potentialize the harmful effects of irradiation resistance (group II freeze-dried grafts), the treated allografts present with changes in their viscoelastic properties that are incompatible with their clinical use. This study has also shown that some parameters influence the extent of the damaging effects of these three treatments, and experiments are being continued to optimize the conservation and sterilization procedure.
同种异体肌腱目前用于前交叉韧带的手术重建。本研究的目的是对保存的人髌腱的力学性能改变进行体外评估,这些髌腱经过深冻或冻干并经伽马射线灭菌处理。从新鲜尸体上取下30对带有骨附着点的髌腱(中间三分之一段),在液氮中冷冻,然后保存在-80℃。每对中,一根肌腱接受额外处理,另一根用作对照。研究了三种处理方式:2.5兆拉德辐照(I组)、残留湿度为1%的冻干处理(II组)、连续冻干和辐照(III组)。解冻后(对照组和I组处理的肌腱),将标本在拉力机上以合适的装置进行力学测试。进行了两种测试:蠕变测试(在0至50牛之间以1赫兹进行80个循环),然后进行极限拉伸强度测试(0.25毫米/秒)。冻干会导致宏观形态改变,如果再进行辐照,这种改变会更加明显。三种处理方式均会导致蠕变增加,极限拉伸强度和杨氏模量降低,且均具有统计学意义。三种处理方式均改变了同种异体移植物的力学性能。冻干能使移植物保持更好的抗拉力。冻干与辐照相结合是最具破坏性的方法,甚至冻干似乎会增强辐照的有害影响(II组冻干移植物),处理后的同种异体移植物呈现出与临床使用不相容的粘弹性特性改变。本研究还表明,一些参数会影响这三种处理的破坏作用程度,目前正在继续进行实验以优化保存和灭菌程序。