Ho K S, West V C
Westmead Hospital, N.S.W.
Aust Orthod J. 1991 Oct;12(2):95-9.
This study quantified the dynamic frictional force encountered when TMA, Orthonol and multistranded stainless steel archwires were pulled a distance of 2mm through ceramic and stainless steel brackets. The current literature is inadequate and incomplete, for example, no data was found on rectangular multistranded archwires. The following factors were investigated: archwire material, archwire size, archwire-to-bracket angulation, bracket material, archwire and bracket slot surface roughness and lubrication in the form of artificial saliva. A total of 156 different combinations were investigated. A universal testing machine was used to pull the ligated archwires through the brackets, and record the friction. A four way analysis of variance with one nesting (archwire size) was carried out on 1,560 measurements to assess the results. All factors and interactions tested were significant in determining friction. Friction was found to increase with: archwire angulation and archwire size (exceptions were seen in some TMA archwires). Friction decreased with lubrication. There was a definite relationship between friction and archwire and bracket material. There was no definite relationship between archwire surface roughness and friction. Highest friction was observed with ceramic bracket and TMA archwire. The range of friction was 1.02 to 9.95 Newtons. The magnitude of the friction recorded is substantially larger than the forces applied in orthodontic movement clinically. It is proposed that the values recorded should be utilised as a means of comparing the effects of different factors, rather than for the quantification of friction in vivo.
本研究对TMA、Orthonol和多股不锈钢弓丝在陶瓷和不锈钢托槽中被拉动2毫米距离时所遇到的动摩擦力进行了量化。当前文献并不充分且不完整,例如,未找到关于矩形多股弓丝的数据。研究了以下因素:弓丝材料、弓丝尺寸、弓丝与托槽的角度、托槽材料、弓丝和托槽槽沟表面粗糙度以及人工唾液形式的润滑。总共研究了156种不同组合。使用万能试验机将结扎好的弓丝拉过托槽,并记录摩擦力。对1560次测量结果进行了带有一个嵌套因素(弓丝尺寸)的四因素方差分析,以评估结果。所有测试的因素及其相互作用在确定摩擦力方面均具有显著性。发现摩擦力随以下因素增加:弓丝角度和弓丝尺寸(在一些TMA弓丝中观察到例外情况)。摩擦力随润滑而降低。摩擦力与弓丝和托槽材料之间存在明确的关系。弓丝表面粗糙度与摩擦力之间没有明确的关系。在陶瓷托槽和TMA弓丝中观察到最高摩擦力。摩擦力范围为1.02至9.95牛顿。记录的摩擦力大小明显大于临床上正畸移动中所施加的力。建议将记录的值用作比较不同因素影响的一种手段,而非用于体内摩擦力的量化。