Kang-Kim Minah, Betancourt Joseph R, Ayanian John Z, Zaslavsky Alan M, Yucel Recai M, Weissman Joel S
Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea.
Med Care. 2008 May;46(5):507-15. doi: 10.1097/MLR.0b013e31816dd966.
State-level disparities in access to physicians and preventive services between Hispanics and whites may have changed over time.
To assess state-based changes in Hispanics' access to physicians and preventive services from 1991 to 2004.
Using data from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System in the 10 states with the largest Hispanic populations, we examined 4 preventive services for eligible adults (mammography, Papanicolaou testing, colorectal cancer screening, and cholesterol testing) and 2 measures of access to physicians (obtaining routine checkup in prior 2 years and avoiding seeing physician when needed due to cost in prior year). In each state we assessed unadjusted and adjusted Hispanic-white access gaps and changes over time.
Hispanic-white access gaps persisted over time and varied widely by state. Disparities narrowed and became nonsignificant in 2 states (Arizona and California) for mammography and 3 states (Nevada, New Mexico, and New York) for Pap testing. Other disparities increased and became significant (mammography in Texas; colorectal cancer screening in California, Colorado, and Texas; cholesterol testing in Florida and Nevada; routine checkups in Arizona and New Mexico). Disparities in lacking doctor visits due to cost remained large and significant over time in all states. Insurance status and education were the main contributors to Hispanic-white disparities and their impact increased over time.
Although use of preventive services and access to physicians improved for both whites and Hispanics nationally, access gaps varied widely among states. Therefore, efforts to monitor and eliminate disparities should be conducted at both the national and state levels.
西班牙裔和白人在获得医生服务及预防服务方面的州级差异可能随时间发生了变化。
评估1991年至2004年西班牙裔在各州获得医生服务及预防服务的变化情况。
利用西班牙裔人口最多的10个州的行为危险因素监测系统的数据,我们对符合条件的成年人的4项预防服务(乳房X线筛查、巴氏试验、结肠直肠癌筛查和胆固醇检测)以及2项获得医生服务的指标(在过去2年进行常规体检以及因前一年费用问题在需要时未就医)进行了研究。在每个州,我们评估了未经调整和调整后的西班牙裔与白人之间的获得服务差距以及随时间的变化。
西班牙裔与白人之间的获得服务差距长期存在,且各州差异很大。在2个州(亚利桑那州和加利福尼亚州),乳房X线筛查的差距缩小并变得不显著;在3个州(内华达州、新墨西哥州和纽约州),巴氏试验的差距缩小并变得不显著。其他差距则有所增加并变得显著(德克萨斯州的乳房X线筛查;加利福尼亚州、科罗拉多州和德克萨斯州的结肠直肠癌筛查;佛罗里达州和内华达州的胆固醇检测;亚利桑那州和新墨西哥州的常规体检)。在所有州中,因费用问题未就医的差距长期以来一直很大且显著。保险状况和教育程度是西班牙裔与白人之间差距的主要促成因素,且其影响随时间增加。
尽管全国范围内白人和西班牙裔在预防服务的使用和获得医生服务方面都有所改善,但各州之间的获得服务差距差异很大。因此,应在国家和州层面开展监测和消除差距的工作。