Price Mark C, Mentzoni Rune A
Psychology Faculty, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Cortex. 2008 Jul-Aug;44(7):890-907. doi: 10.1016/j.cortex.2006.10.003. Epub 2007 Dec 23.
Two experiments compared the SNARC effect for calendar months (January-December) in 16 normal controls against four participants reporting a common but little-studied variety of synaesthesia where ordinal sequences are explicitly experienced in elaborate spatially extended patterns (spatial forms). The SNARC effect (spatial-numerical association of response codes) (Dehaene et al., 1993) in which responses to early versus late members of ordinal sequences show left-hand versus right-hand reaction time (RT) advantages, respectively, has previously provided evidence for implicit associations between sequential and spatial representation in non-synaesthetes (Gevers et al., 2003). The current study revealed an automatic month-SNARC effect for the synaesthetes, with the left/right-hand advantage reversing for synaesthetes who experienced early months on the right rather than the left of their roughly circular year forms. The absence of any month-SNARC effect among 16 controls demonstrated cognitive differences in sequence representation between controls and synaesthetes, but failed to replicate previous findings for non-synaesthetes. Certain details of the synaesthetes' SNARC effect may also constrain the way SNARC effects in non-synaesthetes are interpreted.
两项实验比较了16名正常对照者对日历月份(1月至12月)的SNARC效应,以及4名报告一种常见但研究较少的联觉类型的参与者的SNARC效应,在这种联觉中,有序序列在精细的空间扩展模式(空间形式)中被明确体验。SNARC效应(反应编码的空间-数字关联)(德阿纳等人,1993年),即对有序序列中早期与晚期成员的反应分别显示左手与右手反应时间(RT)优势,此前已为非联觉者中序列与空间表征之间的隐性关联提供了证据(格弗斯等人,2003年)。当前研究揭示了联觉者存在自动的月份-SNARC效应,对于那些在大致圆形的年份形式中右侧而非左侧体验早期月份的联觉者,其左手/右手优势发生了逆转。16名对照者中未出现任何月份-SNARC效应,这表明对照者与联觉者在序列表征上存在认知差异,但未能重复之前关于非联觉者的研究结果。联觉者SNARC效应的某些细节也可能会限制对非联觉者SNARC效应的解释方式。