Cronin-Fenton Deirdre P, Mooney Margaret M, Clegg Limin X, Harlan Linda C
Surveillance Research Program, DCCPS, National Cancer Institute, Bethesda MD 20892-7344, United States.
World J Gastroenterol. 2008 May 28;14(20):3165-73. doi: 10.3748/wjg.14.3165.
To examine the extent of use of specific therapies in clinical practice, and their relationship to therapies validated in clinical trials.
The US National Cancer Institutes' Patterns of Care study was used to examine therapies and survival of patients diagnosed in 2001 with histologically-confirmed gastroesophageal adenocarcinoma (n = 1356). The study re-abstracted data and verified therapy with treating physicians for a population-based stratified random sample.
Approximately 62% of patients had stomach adenocarcinoma (SAC), while 22% had gastric-cardia adenocarcinoma (GCA), and 16% lower esophageal adenocarcinoma (EAC). Stage IV/unstaged esophageal cancer patients were most likely and stage I-III stomach cancer patients least likely to receive chemotherapy as all or part of their therapy; gastric-cardia patients received chemotherapy at a rate between these two. In multivariable analysis by anatomic site, patients 70 years and older were significantly less likely than younger patients to receive chemotherapy alone or chemoradiation for all three anatomic sites. Among esophageal and stomach cancer patients, receipt of chemotherapy was associated with lower mortality; but no association was found among gastric-cardia patients.
This study highlights the relatively low use of clinical trials-validated anti-cancer therapies in community practice. Use of chemotherapy-based treatment was associated with lower mortality, dependent on anatomic site. Findings suggest that physicians treat lower esophageal and SAC as two distinct entities, while gastric-cardia patients receive a mix of the treatment strategies employed for the two other sites.
研究特定疗法在临床实践中的使用程度及其与临床试验中验证的疗法之间的关系。
美国国立癌症研究所的护理模式研究用于调查2001年确诊为组织学确诊的胃食管腺癌患者(n = 1356)的治疗方法和生存率。该研究重新提取数据,并与治疗医生核实了基于人群的分层随机样本的治疗情况。
约62%的患者患有胃腺癌(SAC),22%患有贲门腺癌(GCA),16%患有食管下段腺癌(EAC)。IV期/未分期食管癌患者接受化疗作为全部或部分治疗的可能性最高,而I - III期胃癌患者接受化疗的可能性最低;贲门癌患者接受化疗的比例介于两者之间。在按解剖部位进行的多变量分析中,70岁及以上的患者在所有三个解剖部位单独接受化疗或放化疗的可能性明显低于年轻患者。在食管癌和胃癌患者中,接受化疗与较低的死亡率相关;但在贲门癌患者中未发现相关性。
本研究强调了社区实践中经临床试验验证的抗癌疗法使用相对较少。基于化疗的治疗方法的使用与较低的死亡率相关,这取决于解剖部位。研究结果表明,医生将食管下段癌和胃腺癌视为两个不同实体,而贲门癌患者接受的是用于其他两个部位的治疗策略的混合治疗。