Miotto Paola, Pollini Barbara, Restaneo Antonietta, Favaretto Gerardo, Preti Antonio
Eating Disorders Unit, Department of Mental Health, ULSS 7, Conegliano, TV, Italy.
Compr Psychiatry. 2008 Jul-Aug;49(4):364-73. doi: 10.1016/j.comppsych.2008.01.004. Epub 2008 Mar 19.
Despite evidence of a link between the behavioral and cognitive dimensions of aggressiveness and eating disorders, only few studies have tested this relation empirically.
A total of 112 female patients with anorexia nervosa (n = 61) or bulimia nervosa (n = 51) and 631 young girls attending 7 high schools in the same health district as the patients (northeast Italy) were invited to fill in a set of self-report instruments including the Eating Attitudes Test, the Bulimic Investigatory Test of Edinburgh, the Body Attitudes Test, and the Buss-Perry Aggression Questionnaire (AQ).
In both healthy controls and patients, scores on the measures of eating disorder symptoms were positively related to the scores on the AQ: the strength of the association did not differ between healthy controls and patients. However, patients diagnosed with eating disorders were not more likely to disclose a propensity to aggression than the healthy controls drawn from the community: patients with anorexia nervosa scored lower than controls on the physical aggression and on the verbal aggression subscales of the AQ (P < .05). On the other hand, patients with bulimia nervosa scored higher than controls on the anger subscale of the AQ (P < .05) but did not differ from them on the other subscales of the questionnaire.
The results confirm the higher propensity to anger in patients with bulimia nervosa; in patients with anorexia nervosa, difficulties in expressing anger and outward-directed aggressiveness can be a prevailing feature. The younger age of controls and exclusive reliance on self-report measures might have concealed some differences between patients and community subjects.
尽管有证据表明攻击性的行为和认知维度与饮食失调之间存在联系,但只有少数研究对这种关系进行了实证检验。
共邀请了112名患有神经性厌食症(n = 61)或神经性贪食症(n = 51)的女性患者,以及与这些患者来自同一健康区(意大利东北部)的7所高中的631名年轻女孩,让她们填写一系列自我报告工具,包括饮食态度测试、爱丁堡神经性贪食症调查测试、身体态度测试和布斯-佩里攻击性问卷(AQ)。
在健康对照组和患者中,饮食失调症状测量得分与AQ得分呈正相关:健康对照组和患者之间的关联强度没有差异。然而,被诊断患有饮食失调症的患者并不比从社区中抽取的健康对照组更有可能表现出攻击性倾向:神经性厌食症患者在AQ的身体攻击和言语攻击子量表上的得分低于对照组(P <.05)。另一方面,神经性贪食症患者在AQ的愤怒子量表上的得分高于对照组(P <.05),但在问卷的其他子量表上与对照组没有差异。
结果证实神经性贪食症患者更容易发怒;在神经性厌食症患者中,难以表达愤怒和外向攻击性可能是一个普遍特征。对照组年龄较小以及完全依赖自我报告测量可能掩盖了患者与社区受试者之间的一些差异。