Ram Kerstin Carlin, Eisenberg Elon, Haddad May, Pud Dorit
Faculty of Social Welfare and Health Sciences, University of Haifa, Mount Carmel, Haifa 31905, Israel Pain Relief Unit, Rambam Medical Center, Haifa, Israel The Rappaport Faculty of Medicine, Technion - Israel Institute of Technology, Israel.
Pain. 2008 Oct 15;139(2):431-438. doi: 10.1016/j.pain.2008.05.015. Epub 2008 Jun 25.
Opioids can elicit unexpected changes in pain sensitivity, known as opioid-induced hyperalgesia (OIH). The aim of this study was to explore whether OIH exists in patients with chronic pain treated with oral opioids (OP) versus non-opioid (NOP) analgesics. The sensitivity to cold pain and the magnitude of diffuse noxious inhibitory control (DNIC) were evaluated in 73 OP and 37 NOP treated patients. Pain threshold, intensity and tolerance in response to the cold pressor (1 degrees C) were measured. DNIC was tested by co-administrating conditioned heat stimulation (47 degrees C) to the left forearm and a conditioning stimulation of 12 degrees C for 30s to the right hand. The results showed no differences between the two groups in any of the cold pain measures. In contrast, the magnitude of DNIC was significantly larger in the NOP than in the OP treated patients (p=0.003). A gender based analysis showed a significant difference in DNIC between OP and NOP treated men only. However, a mixed model ANOVA demonstrated a significant effect of treatment (OP versus NOP) (F=5.928, p=0.017) rather than gender on DNIC. A regression analysis showed that opioid dosage and treatment duration had a significant negative effect on the magnitude of DNIC in OP treated men (beta=-2.175, p=0.036 and beta=-2.061, p=0.047, respectively). In conclusion, oral opioids usage for the treatment of chronic pain does not result in abnormal sensitivity to cold pain, but seems to alter pain modulation. The use of 'advanced' psychophysics tests such as evaluation of DNIC can help understanding the phenomenon of OIH.
阿片类药物可引发疼痛敏感性的意外变化,即阿片类药物诱导的痛觉过敏(OIH)。本研究旨在探讨接受口服阿片类药物(OP)与非阿片类药物(NOP)镇痛治疗的慢性疼痛患者中是否存在OIH。对73例接受OP治疗和37例接受NOP治疗的患者进行了冷痛敏感性和弥漫性伤害性抑制控制(DNIC)强度评估。测量了对冷加压刺激(1摄氏度)的疼痛阈值、强度和耐受性。通过向左前臂联合给予条件性热刺激(47摄氏度)和向右手给予12摄氏度的条件刺激30秒来测试DNIC。结果显示,两组在任何冷痛测量指标上均无差异。相比之下,接受NOP治疗的患者DNIC强度显著大于接受OP治疗的患者(p = 0.003)。基于性别的分析显示,仅在接受OP和NOP治疗的男性中,DNIC存在显著差异。然而,混合模型方差分析表明,治疗(OP与NOP)对DNIC有显著影响(F = 5.928,p = 0.017),而非性别。回归分析表明,阿片类药物剂量和治疗持续时间对接受OP治疗的男性的DNIC强度有显著负面影响(β分别为 -2.175,p = 0.036和β = -2.061,p = 0.047)。总之,口服阿片类药物用于治疗慢性疼痛不会导致对冷痛的异常敏感性,但似乎会改变疼痛调节。使用“先进的”心理物理学测试,如DNIC评估,有助于理解OIH现象。