Kakkos S K, Haddad G K, Haddad J A, Scully M M
Division of Vascular Surgery, Department of Surgery, Henry Ford Hospital, Detroit, MI 48202, USA.
Eur J Vasc Endovasc Surg. 2008 Sep;36(3):356-65. doi: 10.1016/j.ejvs.2008.05.007. Epub 2008 Jul 7.
To study the long-term patency of thrombosed prosthetic vascular access grafts treated with percutaneous mechanical thrombectomy (PMT) followed by aggressive surveillance and monitoring and repeated endovascular interventions.
Two hundred seven vascular access grafts presented with first-time thrombosis were treated with PMT using the AngioJet device (n=185) or the Arrow-Trerotola percutaneous thrombolytic device (n=22) followed by angioplasty (+/- stenting) of the anatomical lesion responsible for the thrombotic event. Clinical success was considered at least one successful subsequent hemodialysis session. Graft surveillance/monitoring included clinical and hemodialysis parameters to detect a failing or thrombosed graft.
PMT was technically successful in 202 cases (97.6%) and clinically successful in 193 cases (93.2%). During follow-up, 149 got thrombosed and either abandoned (n=33) or underwent at least once repeat thrombectomy (n=116); finally 100 grafts were abandoned (n=90), ligated (n=5) or removed (n=5). Endovascular management (0.54 procedures per 100 graft-days, thrombectomy, n=307 sessions and angioplasty, n=162 sessions) increased significantly functional assisted-primary patency rates from 29% and 14% at 1 and 2 years to a secondary patency of 62% and 47%, respectively. Secondary patency was worse in loop grafts (P=.02) and intermediate graft thrombosis (occurred between 31-182 days after graft placement, P<.001) and better when renal failure was due to hypertension or diabetes (compared to other or cryptogenic causes, P=.048) or isolated angioplasty for graft dysfunction during follow-up had been performed (P<.001). Multivariate analysis identified intermediate graft thrombosis and isolated angioplasty as independent predictors of secondary patency (P<.001, relative risk 2.77 and P<.001, relative risk 0.28, respectively).
PMT is a highly successful procedure with acceptable long-term secondary patency results, provided that aggressive endovascular management of subsequent thrombotic or dysfunction episode is performed. Further research to identify the causes of intermediate graft thrombosis is justified.
研究经皮机械血栓切除术(PMT)治疗血栓形成的人工血管通路移植物后的长期通畅情况,随后进行积极的监测以及重复的血管内干预。
207例首次出现血栓形成的血管通路移植物接受了PMT治疗,其中185例使用AngioJet装置,22例使用Arrow-Trerotola经皮溶栓装置,随后对导致血栓形成事件的解剖病变进行血管成形术(±支架置入)。临床成功定义为至少有一次后续血液透析治疗成功。移植物监测包括临床和血液透析参数,以检测功能衰竭或血栓形成的移植物。
PMT在技术上成功202例(97.6%),临床成功193例(93.2%)。随访期间,149例发生血栓形成,其中33例被废弃,116例至少接受一次重复血栓切除术;最终100例移植物被废弃(90例)、结扎(5例)或移除(5例)。血管内治疗(每100移植物日0.54次操作,血栓切除术307次,血管成形术162次)显著提高了功能性辅助一期通畅率,从1年和2年时的29%和14%分别提高到二期通畅率的62%和47%。袢状移植物的二期通畅情况较差(P = 0.02),中期移植物血栓形成(发生在移植物置入后31 - 182天之间,P < 0.001)时二期通畅情况也较差,而当肾衰竭由高血压或糖尿病引起时(与其他或不明原因相比,P = 0.048)或随访期间因移植物功能障碍进行单纯血管成形术时二期通畅情况较好(P < 0.001)。多因素分析确定中期移植物血栓形成和单纯血管成形术是二期通畅的独立预测因素(分别为P < 0.001,相对风险2.77;P < 0.001,相对风险0.28)。
PMT是一种非常成功的手术,长期二期通畅结果可接受,前提是对后续血栓形成或功能障碍发作进行积极的血管内治疗。进一步研究确定中期移植物血栓形成的原因是合理的。