Lu Sheng, Chen Xinnian, Kanters Jørgen K, Solomon Irene C, Chon Ki H
Department of Biomedical Engineering, State University of New York (SUNY) Stony Brook, NY 11794, USA.
IEEE Trans Biomed Eng. 2008 Aug;55(8):1966-72. doi: 10.1109/TBME.2008.919870.
Calculation of approximate entropy (ApEn) requires a priori determination of two unknown parameters, m and r. While the recommended values of r, in the range of 0.1-0.2 times the standard deviation of the signal, have been shown to be applicable for a wide variety of signals, in certain cases, r values within this prescribed range can lead to an incorrect assessment of the complexity of a given signal. To circumvent this limitation, we recently advocated finding the maximum ApEn value by assessing all values of r from 0 to 1, and found that maximum ApEn does not always occur within the prescribed range of r values. Our results indicate that finding the maximum ApEn leads to the correct interpretation of a signal's complexity. One major limitation, however, is that the calculation of all choices of r values is often impractical due to the computational burden. Our new method, based on a heuristic stochastic model, overcomes this computational burden, and leads to the automatic selection of the maximum ApEn value for any given signal. Based on Monte Carlo simulations, we derive general equations that can be used to estimate the maximum ApEn with high accuracy for a given value of m. Application to both synthetic and experimental data confirmed the advantages claimed with the proposed approach.
近似熵(ApEn)的计算需要事先确定两个未知参数,即m和r。虽然推荐的r值范围为信号标准差的0.1 - 0.2倍,已被证明适用于多种信号,但在某些情况下,此规定范围内的r值可能导致对给定信号复杂度的错误评估。为规避这一限制,我们最近主张通过评估从0到1的所有r值来找到最大ApEn值,并发现最大ApEn并非总是出现在规定的r值范围内。我们的结果表明,找到最大ApEn可对信号复杂度进行正确解读。然而,一个主要限制是,由于计算负担,计算所有r值的选择通常不切实际。我们基于启发式随机模型的新方法克服了这一计算负担,并能自动为任何给定信号选择最大ApEn值。基于蒙特卡罗模拟,我们推导了可用于在给定m值时高精度估计最大ApEn的通用方程。对合成数据和实验数据的应用证实了所提方法的优势。