Spadaro Joseph V, Rabl Ari
Ecoles des Mines de Paris, Paris, France.
Risk Anal. 2008 Jun;28(3):603-13. doi: 10.1111/j.1539-6924.2008.01041.x.
Since much of the emission is in the form of metallic Hg whose atmospheric residence time is long enough to cause nearly uniform mixing in the hemisphere, much of the impact is global. This article presents a first estimate of global average neurotoxic impacts and costs by defining a comprehensive transfer factor for ingestion of methyl-Hg as ratio of global average dose rate and global emission rate. For the dose-response function (DRF) we use recent estimates of IQ decrement as function of Hg concentration in blood, as well as correlations between blood concentration and Hg ingestion. The cost of an IQ point is taken as $18,000 in the United States and applied in other countries in proportion to per capita GDP, adjusted for purchase power parity. The mean estimate of the global average of the marginal damage cost per emitted kg of Hg is about $1,500/kg, if one assumes a dose threshold of 6.7 mug/day of methyl-Hg per person, and $3,400/kg without threshold. The average global lifetime impact and cost per person at current emission levels are 0.02 IQ points lost and $78 with and 0.087 IQ points and $344 without threshold. These results are global averages; for any particular source and emission site the impacts can be quite different. An assessment of the overall uncertainties indicates that the damage cost could be a factor 4 smaller or larger than the median estimate (the uncertainty distribution is approximately log normal and the ratio median/mean is approximately 0.4).
由于大部分排放物是以金属汞的形式存在,其在大气中的停留时间足够长,足以在半球内实现近乎均匀的混合,因此大部分影响是全球性的。本文通过定义一个综合转移因子来估算甲基汞摄入的全球平均神经毒性影响和成本,该转移因子为全球平均剂量率与全球排放率之比。对于剂量反应函数(DRF),我们使用最近关于智商下降与血液中汞浓度关系的估计值,以及血液浓度与汞摄入量之间的相关性。在美国,一个智商点的成本为18,000美元,并根据购买力平价进行调整后按人均GDP比例应用于其他国家。如果假设每人每天甲基汞的剂量阈值为6.7微克,那么每排放1千克汞的边际损害成本的全球平均估计值约为1,500美元/千克;如果不设阈值,则为3,400美元/千克。在当前排放水平下,全球每人的平均终身影响和成本,有阈值时是损失0.02个智商点和78美元,无阈值时是0.087个智商点和344美元。这些结果是全球平均值;对于任何特定的源和排放地点,影响可能会大不相同。对总体不确定性的评估表明,损害成本可能比中位数估计值小或大4倍(不确定性分布近似对数正态分布,中位数与平均值之比约为0.4)。