Clarke Henry D, Hentz Joseph G
Department of Orthopedic Surgery, Mayo Clinic Arizona, Phoenix, AZ 85054, USA.
Clin Orthop Relat Res. 2008 Nov;466(11):2711-6. doi: 10.1007/s11999-008-0454-6. Epub 2008 Aug 22.
Recent modifications in total knee prosthesis design theoretically better accommodate the anatomy of the female femur and thereby have the theoretical potential to improve clinical results in TKA by more accurately restoring femoral posterior condylar offset, reducing femoral notching, reducing femoral component flexion, and reducing component overhang. First, we radiographically evaluated whether a contemporary unisex prosthesis would accommodate female anatomy equally as well as male anatomy. Next, we radiographically evaluated female knees in which a gender-specific prosthesis was used. Pre- and postoperative radiographs of 122 knees (42 female unisex, 41 male unisex, 39 female gender-specific) were reviewed. In the unisex groups, there were no differences in femoral notching or femoral component flexion. Posterior femoral offset increased in both groups. However, femoral component overhang was worse in female knees (17%) than in male knees (0%). In the gender-specific female group, the incidence of component overhang was similar to that in the unisex female group. Unisex femoral components of this specific design do not equally match the native anatomy male and female knees. In some women, a compromise was required in sizing.
全膝关节假体设计的近期改进理论上能更好地适应女性股骨的解剖结构,从而有可能通过更精确地恢复股骨后髁偏移、减少股骨切迹、减少股骨部件的屈曲以及减少部件悬垂,来改善全膝关节置换术(TKA)的临床效果。首先,我们通过影像学评估一种当代通用型假体对女性解剖结构的适应程度是否与男性解剖结构相同。接下来,我们对使用了特定性别的假体的女性膝关节进行了影像学评估。回顾了122个膝关节(42个女性通用型、41个男性通用型、39个女性特定性别型)的术前和术后X线片。在通用型组中,股骨切迹或股骨部件的屈曲没有差异。两组的股骨后偏移均增加。然而,女性膝关节的股骨部件悬垂(17%)比男性膝关节(0%)更严重。在特定性别的女性组中,部件悬垂的发生率与通用型女性组相似。这种特定设计的通用型股骨部件并不能同等地匹配男性和女性膝关节的自然解剖结构。在一些女性中,尺寸选择需要做出妥协。