Minati Ludovico, Rosazza Cristina, Zucca Ileana, D'Incerti Ludovico, Scaioli Vidmer, Bruzzone Maria Grazia
Science Direction Unit, Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Neurologico Carlo Besta, Via Celoria 11, 20133, Milano, MI, Italy.
Brain Topogr. 2008 Dec;21(2):112-27. doi: 10.1007/s10548-008-0064-3. Epub 2008 Aug 29.
We investigated the spatial correspondence between functional MRI (fMRI) activations and cortical current density maps of event-related potentials (ERPs) reconstructed without fMRI priors. The presence of a significant spatial correspondence is a prerequisite for direct integration of the two modalities, enabling to combine the high spatial resolution of fMRI with the high temporal resolution of ERPs. Four separate tasks were employed: visual stimulation with a pattern-reversal chequerboard, recognition of images of nameable objects, recognition of written words, and auditory stimulation with a piano note. ERPs were acquired with 19 recording channels, and source localisation was performed using a realistic head model, a standard cortical mesh and the multiple sparse priors method. Spatial correspondence was evaluated at group level over 10 subjects, by means of a voxel-by-voxel test and a test on the distribution of local maxima. Although not complete, it was significant for the visual stimulation task, image and word recognition tasks (P < 0.001 for both types of test), but not for the auditory stimulation task. These findings indicate that partial but significant spatial correspondence between the two modalities can be found even with a small number of channels, for three of the four tasks employed. Absence of correspondence for the auditory stimulation task was caused by the unfavourable situation of the activated cortex being perpendicular to the overlying scalp, whose consequences were exacerbated by the small number of channels. The present study corroborates existing literature in this field, and may be of particular relevance to those interested in combining fMRI with ERPs acquired with the standard 10-20 system.
我们研究了功能磁共振成像(fMRI)激活与在无fMRI先验条件下重建的事件相关电位(ERP)皮质电流密度图之间的空间对应关系。显著空间对应关系的存在是两种模态直接整合的先决条件,能够将fMRI的高空间分辨率与ERP的高时间分辨率相结合。采用了四项不同的任务:用模式反转棋盘进行视觉刺激、可命名物体图像识别、书面单词识别以及用钢琴音符进行听觉刺激。通过19个记录通道采集ERP,并使用逼真的头部模型、标准皮质网格和多重稀疏先验方法进行源定位。通过逐体素测试和局部最大值分布测试,在10名受试者的群体水平上评估空间对应关系。虽然并不完全对应,但在视觉刺激任务、图像和单词识别任务中具有显著对应关系(两种测试类型的P均<0.001),而在听觉刺激任务中则不然。这些发现表明,对于所采用的四项任务中的三项,即使使用少量通道,也能发现两种模态之间存在部分但显著的空间对应关系。听觉刺激任务中缺乏对应关系是由于激活的皮质垂直于头皮的不利情况导致的,而通道数量少加剧了这种情况的后果。本研究证实了该领域的现有文献,对于那些有兴趣将fMRI与通过标准10 - 20系统采集的ERP相结合的人可能具有特别的相关性。