Gooi Malcolm, Bell Chaim M
Faculty of Medicine, University of Toronto, Toronto, Canada.
Appl Health Econ Health Policy. 2008;6(1):19-26. doi: 10.2165/00148365-200806010-00002.
It has long been recognized that brand name prescription medications are more expensive in the US than in Canada. However, non-peer-reviewed reports contend that this is not the case for generic medications.
To compare prices for generic prescription medications in the US and Canada.
A telephone and internet survey of pharmacies was conducted for the top 19 dispensed generic medications available in both countries. Twelve pharmacies in total were selected: six from the US (three online and three 'walk-in') and six from Canada (three online and three walk-in). Data were collected from March to April 2007.The main outcome measure was the total purchase price in $US at the day's exchange rate in 2007, obtained from each of the 12 pharmacies, for 100 doses of each of the 19 selected drugs.
Using the lowest quote for each selected drug, 12 of the 19 (63%) generic medications were least expensive in the US, with an average saving of 47% per drug for these 12 drugs. Seven of the 19 (37%) drugs were least expensive in Canada, with an average saving of 29% per drug for these seven drugs. Overall, there was a sizable variation in prices for the same generic medications within and between the US and Canada.
The lowest priced generic medications were not consistently found in either the US or Canada. The price controls and ensuing savings applied in Canada to prescription patented medications do not fully extend to generic medications.
长期以来,人们一直认识到美国品牌名处方药的价格比加拿大更高。然而,未经同行评审的报告称,非专利药并非如此。
比较美国和加拿大非专利处方药的价格。
对两国最常配发的19种非专利药进行了电话和网络药店调查。总共选择了12家药店:美国6家(3家在线药店和3家实体药店)和加拿大6家(3家在线药店和3家实体药店)。数据收集于2007年3月至4月。主要结果指标是按照2007年当日汇率换算成美元的总购买价格,从12家药店中的每家获取,针对19种选定药物中的每种药物各100剂。
对于每种选定药物,采用最低报价,19种非专利药中有12种(63%)在美国最便宜,这12种药物每种平均节省47%。19种药物中有7种(37%)在加拿大最便宜,这7种药物每种平均节省29%。总体而言,美国和加拿大境内及两国之间相同非专利药的价格存在相当大的差异。
在美国或加拿大都未能始终找到价格最低的非专利药。加拿大对专利处方药实施的价格管制及由此带来的节省并未完全适用于非专利药。