Wong Andrew S, Jebson Peter J L, Murray Peter M, Trigg Stephen D
Department of Orthopaedic Surgery, University of Michigan Health System, Ann Arbor, MI, 48109-0328, USA.
Hand (N Y). 2007 Sep;2(3):117-9. doi: 10.1007/s11552-007-9032-8. Epub 2007 Mar 29.
The purpose of this study was to evaluate the cost-effectiveness of routine wrist radiography in the evaluation of patients with a wrist ganglion. In the setting of a University-based hand surgery practice, 103 consecutive patients with a dorsal or volar wrist ganglion underwent posteroanterior, lateral, and oblique radiographs of the involved wrist. There were 24 men and 79 women with an average age of 34 years (range 4-67 years). A retrospective review of the medical records was performed. Abnormalities on plain radiographs were noted in only 13 patients (13%). Findings included six cases of thumb carpometacarpal joint arthritis and one case each of an enchondroma, congenital distal radioulnar joint (DRUJ) anomaly, DRUJ degenerative changes, intraosseous ganglion, carpal boss, radiocarpal arthritis, and thumb metacarpophalangeal joint osteoarthritis. In only one case (1%) did the findings alter the management. At our institution, the professional and technical charge for three views of the wrist is $172. This confers a cost of $17,716 per therapeutically significant finding in our series. We conclude that routinely performing wrist radiography is not cost-effective in the evaluation and treatment decision-making process in patients with a wrist ganglion.
本研究的目的是评估常规腕关节X线摄影在腕部腱鞘囊肿患者评估中的成本效益。在一所大学附属医院的手外科诊所,103例连续的背侧或掌侧腕部腱鞘囊肿患者接受了患侧腕关节的正位、侧位和斜位X线摄影。其中男性24例,女性79例,平均年龄34岁(范围4 - 67岁)。对病历进行了回顾性分析。仅13例患者(13%)在X线平片上发现异常。结果包括6例拇指腕掌关节关节炎,1例内生软骨瘤、1例先天性下尺桡关节(DRUJ)异常、1例DRUJ退行性变、1例骨内腱鞘囊肿、1例腕部隆突、1例桡腕关节炎和1例拇指掌指关节骨关节炎。仅1例(1%)的检查结果改变了治疗方案。在我们机构,腕关节三个投照位的专业和技术收费为172美元。在我们的系列研究中,每一个具有治疗意义的检查结果的成本为17,716美元。我们得出结论,在腕部腱鞘囊肿患者的评估和治疗决策过程中,常规进行腕关节X线摄影不具有成本效益。