Alavi Mehrossadat, Emad Ali Farid, Bahtouee Mehrzad
Department of Nuclear Medicine, Shiraz University of Medical Sciences, Shiraz, Iran.
Hell J Nucl Med. 2008 May-Aug;11(2):110-3.
In cases of chronic pulmonary tuberculosis (PTB) with negative sputum smears, particularly when they are symptomatic, physicians encounter problems in differentiating the active from the inactive stage of the disease. This study was undertaken to determine the usefulness of technetium-99m hexakis methoxy isobutyl isonitrile ((99m)Tc-MIBI) pulmonary scintigraphy and lactic dehydrogenase (LDH) in bronchoalveolar lavage fluid (BALF), in differentiating active from inactive PTB. According to the methods we used, BALF LDH level was measured in 12 patients with documented active PTB (Group 1) before of treatment and in 7 patients with treated PTB (Group 2) after treatment. Lung scan with (99m)Tc-MIBI was performed in 7/12 patients of Group 1 (Group 1a) and in all of Group 2. Five patients of Group 1 refused the lung scan (Group 1b). Five adults who had a normal myocardial perfusion scan were considered as normal lung cases (Group 3). Our results showed that the mean LDH level in BALF was not statistically higher in Group 1 (252.42+/-189.06 mIU/ml) than in Group 2 (106.28+/-139.99 mIU/ml). Very low values, less than 24 mIu/ml, excluded active PTB. Of the 7 patients of Group 1a, 6 had a positive lung scan (85.7%). Of the 7 patients of Group 2, 6 had negative lung scan (85.7%). Both tests had a positive correlation in differentiating active and inactive PTB. In conclusion, although none of the tests were specific for PTB, low BALF LDH of less than 24 mIUL and negative (99m)Tc-MIBI pulmonary scintigraphy, seemed to indicate inactive PTB. If our findings are confirmed by others with more related cases, these tests can be shown useful in the follow up of treated PTB patients.
在痰涂片阴性的慢性肺结核(PTB)病例中,尤其是出现症状时,医生在区分疾病的活动期和非活动期方面会遇到问题。本研究旨在确定锝-99m 六甲基异丁基异腈((99m)Tc-MIBI)肺闪烁扫描和支气管肺泡灌洗(BALF)液中的乳酸脱氢酶(LDH)在区分活动性与非活动性 PTB 方面的效用。根据我们采用的方法,在 12 例确诊为活动性 PTB 的患者(第 1 组)治疗前以及 7 例接受过治疗的 PTB 患者(第 2 组)治疗后测量了 BALF 中的 LDH 水平。第 1 组的 7/12 例患者(第 1a 组)和第 2 组的所有患者均进行了(99m)Tc-MIBI 肺扫描。第 1 组的 5 例患者拒绝进行肺扫描(第 1b 组)。5 例心肌灌注扫描正常的成年人被视为正常肺病例(第 3 组)。我们的结果显示,第 1 组(252.42±189.06 mIU/ml)BALF 中的平均 LDH 水平在统计学上并不高于第 2 组(106.28±139.99 mIU/ml)。极低值,即低于 24 mIu/ml,可排除活动性 PTB。第 1a 组的 7 例患者中,6 例肺扫描呈阳性(85.7%)。第 2 组的 7 例患者中,6 例肺扫描呈阴性(85.7%)。在区分活动性与非活动性 PTB 方面,这两项检查具有正相关性。总之,尽管这些检查均非 PTB 的特异性检查,但 BALF 中 LDH 低于 24 mIUL 以及(99m)Tc-MIBI 肺闪烁扫描阴性似乎表明为非活动性 PTB。如果我们的研究结果能被更多相关病例的其他人所证实,这些检查在已治疗的 PTB 患者随访中可能会被证明是有用的。