School of Health and Rehabilitation Sciences, The University of Queensland, Brisbane, Qld, Australia.
Int J Lang Commun Disord. 2009 May-Jun;44(3):253-70. doi: 10.1080/13682820802090281.
Speech perception is often considered specific to the auditory modality, despite convincing evidence that speech processing is bimodal. The theoretical and clinical roles of speech-reading for speech perception, however, have received little attention in speech-language therapy.
The role of speech-read information for speech perception is evaluated by considering evidence from hearing infants and adults, people with speech disorders, and those born profoundly hearing impaired.
METHODS & PROCEDURES: Research studies are evaluated for evidence on lip-reading for speech perception: the mandatory role of speech-reading for hearing adults' perception of the McGurk effect and hearing infants' awareness of the congruence between lip movements and speech sounds; brain neuroimaging studies of speech-read and heard speech perception; the speech-reading abilities of people with disordered speech; and the phonological coding abilities of people with profound pre-lingual hearing loss. Theories of multimodal speech perception are explained.
Five pieces of evidence indicate that speech-reading is an integral part of speech processing. Hearing people's perception of speech is influenced by speech-read cues, and those speech-read cues cannot be ignored. Infants are aware that lip movements and speech sounds match from soon after birth and by four months of age have language specific speech-reading skills. Studies of brain activity show that the brain processes speech-read and heard speech similarly. Some children and adults with speech disorders are reported to rely less on speech-read cues than people without speech disorders, and children who are profoundly hearing impaired from birth have concepts of rhyme, match homophones, and can repeat and spell nonsense words.
CONCLUSIONS & IMPLICATIONS: Speech-reading, a mandatory part of speech perception, should be appropriately assessed and be considered when developing strategies for speech and language intervention.
尽管有令人信服的证据表明言语处理是双模态的,但言语感知通常被认为是特定于听觉模式的。然而,在言语语言治疗中,言语阅读对言语感知的理论和临床作用却很少受到关注。
通过考虑来自听力婴儿和成人、言语障碍者以及先天重度听力受损者的证据,评估言语阅读信息对言语感知的作用。
评估研究证据,了解唇读对言语感知的作用:言语阅读对听力成人感知麦格克效应和听力婴儿感知唇动与言语声音之间一致性的强制性作用;言语阅读和听力言语感知的大脑神经影像学研究;言语障碍者的言语阅读能力;以及先天失聪前语言重度听力损失者的语音编码能力。解释多模态言语感知理论。
有五方面的证据表明,唇读是言语处理的一个组成部分。听力者的言语感知受到唇读线索的影响,这些唇读线索不容忽视。婴儿从出生后不久就意识到唇动与言语声音的匹配,到四个月大时就具有语言特定的唇读技能。大脑活动研究表明,大脑以相似的方式处理唇读和听到的言语。一些言语障碍的儿童和成人被报告比没有言语障碍的人较少依赖唇读线索,而先天重度失聪的儿童则具有押韵、匹配同音词的概念,并且可以重复和拼写无意义的单词。
唇读作为言语感知的强制性组成部分,应该得到适当的评估,并在制定言语和语言干预策略时加以考虑。