Ho Sunita P, Yu Bo, Yun Wenbing, Marshall Grayson W, Ryder Mark I, Marshall Sally J
Division of Biomaterials and Bioengineering, Department of Preventive and Restorative Dental Sciences, UCSF, 707 Parnassus Avenue, San Francisco, CA 94143-0758, USA.
Acta Biomater. 2009 Feb;5(2):707-18. doi: 10.1016/j.actbio.2008.08.013. Epub 2008 Sep 9.
This work seeks to establish comparisons of the physical properties of rat and human cementum, root dentin and their interface, including the cementum-dentin junction (CDJ), as a basis for future studies of the entire periodontal complex using rats as animal models. In this study the structure, site-specific chemical composition and mechanical properties of cementum and its interface with root dentin taken from 9- to 12-month-old rats were compared to the physiologically equivalent 40- to 55-year-old human age group using qualitative and quantitative characterization techniques, including histology, atomic force microscopy (AFM), micro-X-ray computed tomography, Raman microspectroscopy and AFM-based nanoindentation. Based on results from this study, cementum taken from the apical third of the respective species can be represented as a woven fabric with radially and circumferentially oriented collagen fibers. In both species the attachment of cementum to root dentin is defined by a stiffness-graded interface (CDJ/cementum-dentin interface). However, it was concluded that cementum and the cementum-dentin interface from a 9- to 12-month-old rat could be more mineralized, resulting in noticeably decreased collagen fiber hydration and significantly higher modulus values under wet conditions for cementum and CDJ (E(rat-cementum)=12.7+/-2.6 GPa; E(rat-CDJ)=11.6+/-3.2 GPa) compared to a 40- to 55-year-old human (E(human-cementum)=3.73+/-1.8 GPa; E(human-CDJ)=1.5+/-0.7 GPa). The resulting data illustrated that the extensions of observations made from animal models to humans should be justified with substantial and equivalent comparison of data across age ranges (life spans) of mammalian species.
这项工作旨在对大鼠和人类的牙骨质、牙根牙本质及其界面(包括牙骨质 - 牙本质界(CDJ))的物理特性进行比较,为未来以大鼠作为动物模型研究整个牙周复合体奠定基础。在本研究中,使用定性和定量表征技术,包括组织学、原子力显微镜(AFM)、微计算机断层扫描、拉曼光谱和基于AFM的纳米压痕技术,将取自9至12月龄大鼠的牙骨质及其与牙根牙本质界面的结构、特定部位化学成分和力学性能,与生理上相当的40至55岁人类年龄组进行比较。基于本研究结果,取自各物种根尖三分之一处的牙骨质可表示为具有径向和周向取向胶原纤维的编织物。在两个物种中,牙骨质与牙根牙本质的附着均由刚度渐变界面(CDJ/牙骨质 - 牙本质界面)定义。然而,得出的结论是,9至12月龄大鼠的牙骨质和牙骨质 - 牙本质界面矿化程度可能更高,导致胶原纤维水合作用明显降低,并且在潮湿条件下,牙骨质和CDJ的模量值显著更高(E(大鼠牙骨质)=12.7±2.6 GPa;E(大鼠CDJ)=11.6±3.2 GPa),相比之下,40至55岁人类的相应值为(E(人类牙骨质)=3.73±1.8 GPa;E(人类CDJ)=1.5±0.7 GPa)。所得数据表明,从动物模型到人类的观察结果扩展应以跨哺乳动物物种年龄范围(寿命)的数据进行充分且等效的比较为依据。