Morana Claire, Ramdani Sofiane, Perrey Stéphane, Varray Alain
EA 2991 Motor Efficiency and Deficiency Laboratory, University of Montpellier 1, Faculty of Sport Sciences, 700 Avenue du Pic Saint Loup, 34090 Montpellier, France.
J Neurosci Methods. 2009 Feb 15;177(1):73-9. doi: 10.1016/j.jneumeth.2008.09.023. Epub 2008 Oct 8.
This study aimed to assess the capacity of recurrence quantification analysis (RQA) to detect potentiation and to determine the fatigue components to which RQA is sensitive. Fifteen men were divided in two groups [8 endurance-trained athletes (END) and 7 power-trained athletes (POW)]. They performed a 10-min intermittent (5s contraction, 5s rest) knee extension exercise at 50% of their maximal voluntary isometric contraction. Muscular fatigue and potentiation were evaluated with neurostimulation technique. Mechanical (peak torque, Pt) and electrophysiological (M-wave) responses following electrical stimulation of the femoral nerve were measured at rest and every 10s throughout exercise. Vastus lateralis muscle activity (root mean square, RMS) was recorded during each contraction, and RMS was normalized to M-wave area (RMS/M). During contraction, muscle activity was analyzed with RQA to obtain the percentage of determinism (%Det). At the beginning of exercise, a significant Pt increase (+52%, P<0.001) was observed in both groups, indicating potentiation. At this time, %Det remained constant in both groups, indicating that RQA did not detect potentiation. Thereafter, Pt decreased in POW from 5min 30s of exercise (-30%, P<0.001), reflecting impairment in excitation-contraction coupling, and %Det increased from 3min 30s (P<0.01). In END, Pt remained high and %Det was unchanged. These two results indicated that RQA detected the peripheral component of fatigue. Conversely, RQA did not detect central adaptation to fatigue since %Det remained constant when a significant increase in RMS/M (P<0.01) appeared in END.
本研究旨在评估递归定量分析(RQA)检测增强作用的能力,并确定RQA敏感的疲劳成分。15名男性被分为两组[8名耐力训练运动员(END)和7名力量训练运动员(POW)]。他们以最大自主等长收缩的50%进行了10分钟的间歇性(5秒收缩,5秒休息)膝关节伸展运动。采用神经刺激技术评估肌肉疲劳和增强作用。在休息时以及运动过程中每10秒测量一次股神经电刺激后的机械反应(峰值扭矩,Pt)和电生理反应(M波)。在每次收缩期间记录股外侧肌活动(均方根,RMS),并将RMS标准化为M波面积(RMS/M)。在收缩期间,用RQA分析肌肉活动以获得确定性百分比(%Det)。运动开始时,两组均观察到显著的Pt增加(+52%,P<0.001),表明存在增强作用。此时,两组的%Det均保持不变,表明RQA未检测到增强作用。此后,POW组从运动5分30秒开始Pt下降(-30%,P<0.001),反映出兴奋-收缩偶联受损,%Det从3分30秒开始增加(P<0.01)。在END组中,Pt保持较高水平且%Det不变。这两个结果表明RQA检测到了疲劳的外周成分。相反,RQA未检测到对疲劳的中枢适应,因为当END组的RMS/M显著增加(P<0.01)时,%Det保持不变。