Gomes L, Livesey D
School of Psychology, University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia.
Child Care Health Dev. 2008 Nov;34(6):763-70. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2214.2008.00878.x.
In recent years there has been an increased interest in the behavioural correlates of poor peer relations in childhood. It is now apparent that early poor peer relations are associated with negative future outcomes. The present study investigated whether behaviours that reflect impulsivity or require response inhibition are uniquely linked to children's peer relations.
Five- and 6-year-old children's impulsivity was assessed using the teacher-rated impulsivity scale (TRIS), while the stop signal task and a modified version of Manly et al.'s opposite worlds task were employed as measures of response inhibition. In addition, peer relations measures were obtained for each child by asking their peers to indicate on a peer rating scale how much they would like to play with them.
It was found that children's scores on the TRIS correlated significantly with peer relations measures (sociometric preference, peer acceptance and peer rejection) after controlling for gender, age and intelligence. Children rated by their teachers to be more impulsive had poorer peer relations. While there was a significant correlation between TRIS and stop-signal task performance, little relationship was found between either of the response inhibition measures and children's peer relations.
The findings indicate that impulsivity is associated with children's poor relations with their peers and that this association is dependent upon the measure of impulsivity used. Whereas the more subjective teacher-ratings of impulsiveness did correlate with peer relations, the more objective behavioural measures of response inhibition, (thought to directly measure impulsivity), did not. The difference between these measures needs further investigation. While the data are correlational and causal direction can only be speculated, a practical implication of the finding of an association between impulsivity and peer acceptance is that adoption of strategies to minimize impulsive behaviour may improve the poor peer relations of children.
近年来,人们对儿童时期同伴关系不良的行为关联越来越感兴趣。现在很明显,早期同伴关系不良与未来的负面结果相关。本研究调查了反映冲动性或需要反应抑制的行为是否与儿童的同伴关系有独特的联系。
使用教师评定冲动性量表(TRIS)对5岁和6岁儿童的冲动性进行评估,同时采用停止信号任务和曼利等人的“相反世界”任务的修改版作为反应抑制的测量方法。此外,通过让每个孩子的同伴在同伴评定量表上指出他们有多愿意和他们一起玩,来获得每个孩子的同伴关系测量结果。
发现在控制了性别、年龄和智力之后,儿童在TRIS上的得分与同伴关系测量结果(社会测量偏好、同伴接纳和同伴拒绝)显著相关。教师评定为更冲动的儿童同伴关系较差。虽然TRIS与停止信号任务表现之间存在显著相关性,但在任何一种反应抑制测量与儿童同伴关系之间几乎没有发现关系。
研究结果表明,冲动性与儿童与同伴的不良关系有关,而且这种关联取决于所使用的冲动性测量方法。虽然更主观的教师冲动性评定与同伴关系相关,但更客观的反应抑制行为测量(被认为直接测量冲动性)却并非如此。这些测量方法之间的差异需要进一步研究。虽然数据是相关性的,因果方向只能推测,但冲动性与同伴接纳之间存在关联这一发现的一个实际意义是,采用策略来尽量减少冲动行为可能会改善儿童不良的同伴关系。