Kind Terry, Everett Veronica R, Ottolini Mary
Division of General Pediatrics and Community Health, Children's National Medical Center, United States.
Patient Educ Couns. 2009 May;75(2):149-54. doi: 10.1016/j.pec.2008.09.011. Epub 2008 Nov 13.
Reflective writing is an established method for teaching medical students empathetic interactions, though little is known about students' reflections on connecting with patients during the clinical clerkship. The purpose of this study was to describe factors that medical students perceive contribute to or detract from making connections with patients and families, as identified in a writing assignment during the pediatric clinical clerkship.
Reflective essays submitted by third-year medical students about interacting with patients/families during their pediatric clerkship were qualitatively analyzed for thematic content.
Major themes emerging in 44 essays analyzed included time, knowledge, language and culture, and actions. Barriers to connecting for some students were considered resources by others. Critical reflection was present in 31.8%.
Students' perceptions of factors that influence their interactions with patients and families will enhance or detract their ability to make connections. Through reflection, medical students - amidst clinical responsibilities - can identify how, why, and whether or not connections with patients/families have occurred.
Recognizing what factors medical students perceive as enhancing and detracting from connecting with patients/families will help preceptors foster those connections and mitigate barriers. Future study could assess how to best provide specific individualized feedback to best enhance critical reflection. We recommend the inclusion of brief reflective writing exercises during clinical clerkships in medical school, as it may augment students' ability to connect.
反思性写作是一种用于教授医学生共情互动的既定方法,不过对于学生在临床实习期间与患者建立联系的反思了解甚少。本研究的目的是描述医学生在儿科临床实习期间的一篇写作作业中所确定的、他们认为有助于或不利于与患者及家属建立联系的因素。
对三年级医学生提交的关于其儿科实习期间与患者/家属互动的反思性文章进行主题内容的定性分析。
在分析的44篇文章中出现的主要主题包括时间、知识、语言和文化以及行为。对一些学生而言构成建立联系障碍的因素,对另一些学生来说则被视为资源。批判性反思出现在31.8%的文章中。
学生对影响其与患者及家属互动的因素的认知会增强或削弱他们建立联系的能力。通过反思,医学生在履行临床职责的过程中能够确定与患者/家属建立联系的方式、原因以及是否已经建立联系。
认识到医学生认为哪些因素有助于或不利于与患者/家属建立联系,将有助于带教老师促进这些联系并消除障碍。未来的研究可以评估如何最好地提供具体的个性化反馈,以最有效地增强批判性反思。我们建议在医学院临床实习期间纳入简短的反思性写作练习,因为这可能会增强学生建立联系的能力。